CANADA’S CULTURAL GENOCIDE

Christianity was imposed and traditional native beliefs outlawed. Mortality rates reflected the abuse with many buried in unmarked graves, many others simply disappeared.

The dislocation of indigenous  families and communities was complete, those who returned to their families found it impossible to re assimilate  to what had become for many an alien culture they could not accept and where they were rejected.

The Truth and Reconciliation Commission reviewed the consequences of the legacy of the residential school system and in 2014 made 94 ‘Calls to Action’; one of these recommended a papal apology delivered on Canadian soil. Justin Trudeau the Canadian Prime Minister lobbied for this when he visited the Vatican in May 2014.  In December the  bishops of Saskatchewan issued a further invitation to the pope.The question of a papal visit had not been on the agenda when Canadian bishops held their annual plenary in Ontario in September. Bishop Douglas Crosby of Hamilton, Ontario, outgoing  president of the Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops said in October  “the matter had to be considered carefully because it can be really expensive…. ”  When bishop  Lionel Gendron became president he said the bishops were in a process of ‘discernment’ regarding a papal visit. In March 2018  bishop  Gendron, confirmed that Pope Francis would not be delivering an apology: ‘after carefully considering the request  and extensive dialogue with the bishops of Canada, he (the pope) felt that he could not personally respond”

Bishop Gendron added, ‘a future  papal visit to Canada may be considered”… stressing that reconciliation   “remains a major pastoral priority”… “We look forward to a future where systemic injustices are meaningfully addressed, where we all discover new ways of living together through which the First Peoples of this land are honoured and respected,”  “We have heard your invitation to engage honestly and courageously with the past, to acknowledge the failings of members of the Catholic Church, and to take active steps of solidarity with indigenous peoples toward a better future,” he wrote.  Bishop Gendron’s statement only proves that the invitation has not ‘been heard’ for hearing requires listening. Reconciliation is dependent upon acceptance of wrong doing, this is not the same as looking forward to a happier time. The pope as the head of the church symbolises and carries responsibility for its actions and their outcome. The comments of the catholic hierarchy are a sad reflection of their inability to acknowledge either.

The Pope’s decision pushed an all party vote in the Canadian parliament on May 1st 2018 to renew the invitation to Pope Francis to apologise on Canadian soil. It was carried by 169 -10. and  also calls on the Catholic Church to pay money owed to residential school survivors and to turn over relevant documentation regarding the government-sponsored schools. Perhaps the comment by bishop Cosby concerning the invitation to apologise ( “the matter had to be considered carefully because it can be really expensive.”)  is telling. It serves as a reminder of the expense which will or should be incurred by the catholic church in settling the many court actions by survivors of abuse which would follow an admission of guilt and yet without it healing can not begin.

As the bishops and indeed the pope ponder on discernment, a definition of which is ‘sharp perception based on wisdom and justice’ we are humbled by the dignity of those who have not only suffered but have been ignored for so long. While financial compensation can never restore the lost childhoods and lost families it could begin to restore the dignity of the church.

See: Letters to Priests

 

 

PAPAL APOLOGIES – GENOCIDE LIST

“An excuse is worse and more terrible than a lie, for an excuse is a lie guarded”                                                     — Pope John Paul II 

Pope John Paul made many apologies during his pontificate, allowing the healing process to begin.

See: Canada, Child Abuse – Francis refuses invitation to apologise

Follow:  Letters to Priests

HUMANITARIAN MISSILES!

Peace is only ever achieved by refusing to compromise integrity. While we may be far from an ability to ‘turn the other cheek’ against any assault, real or imagined, violence will only ever perpetuate violence.  War is the preferred option for those with a vested interest in warfare, however tenuous. Sometimes it takes a little time to discern who benefits,  by their action,  by looking the other way or predictably financially.

The 8 Storm Shadow missiles fired by the UK on a presumed chemical facility in Syria were manufactured by BAE Systems; each cost £790,000 or $1,106,628. Sickeningly BAE saw an immediate and dramatic rise in share profits on the stock market following the bombing of Syria.

BAE Systems plc is a British multinational defence, security, and aerospace company. It is among the world’s largest defence companies and one of the six largest suppliers to the US. , which is the largest share holder in BAE Systems. Capital Group is also the second largest shareholder in Lockheed Martin a US military arms firm supplying weapons systems, aircraft and logistical support. Unsurprisingly its shares have also rocketed following the strike. Continue reading →

ASSANGE – Free Speech!

Back in the news again doing what he does best: Julian Assange might be expected to comment on what he perceives as human rights abuses including the current situation relating to the Catalonian Independence movement and Spain’s request to Germany to extradite their former leader Carles Puigdemont on charges of Rebellion. Assange has angered the new Ecuadorian President, Lenin Moreno, with his comments which embassy officials stated ”put at risk the good relations Ecuador maintains with European nations’.

Julian Assange has now had his internet access cut by embassy staff and is not allowed visitors or telephone calls, further increasing his isolation within the embassy. His  comments referenced a previous Spanish extradition warrant:  ‘In 1940 the elected president of Catalonia was captured by the Gestapo at the request of Spain, delivered to them and executed. Today German police have arrested the elected president of Catalonia,Carles Puigdemont at the request of Spain, to be extradited’ Ironically Germany has refused the extradition warrant stating that the charge of Rebellion would not be upheld in Germany. Extradition on a lesser charge of misappropriation of funds is possible, carrying an 8 years sentence as opposed to 30 years; if this is taken, it is believed Puigdemont could not then be tried in Spain for Rebellion.

President Moreno holds a differing ‘as long as we assume his life may be in danger’.Since the new government is seeking to realign with the US, Assange may find himself a political pawn in the international power game. If a deal were struck to guarantee that no death penalty would be sought in any future US trial, Ecuador might be released from the current untenable situation  in harbouring Assange and find favour with the US. Julian Assange would lose his asylum status and would be arrested on leaving the embassy, his extradition to Sweden and likely the US would follow.

Julian Assange is either a dissident political prisoner or is guilty of treason depending upon your point of view. He founded Wikileaks in 2006,  publishing a series of leaks in 2010 provided by former soldier Chelsea Manning. They include the Collateral Murder video, the Afghanistan war logs, the Iraq war logs, and Cablegate. Chelsea Manning who passed thousands of documents to Wikileaks, was charged with espionage and sentenced to 35 years imprisonment (commuted after 7 years by President Barack Obama).  The further leaks by Edward Snowden, raised awareness of the US governmental data breaches involving spying on citizens and world leaders resulted in him fleeing the US, before being granted asylum in Russia, where he has resided for almost 5 years.The  federal government of the United States launched a criminal investigation into Wikileaks and asked allied nations for assistance. US Senators have called for the death penalty for Julian Assange  for ‘aiding the enemy’  if he is returned to the US, the risk is therefore real.

In an effort to avoid extradition Assange was granted asylum in the Ecuadorian Embasasy where he has resided for the past 5 years in what the UN has described as ‘illegal detention’. The UK Metropolitan Police continue to assert that he will be arrested if he leaves the embassy. The United Nations Working Group on Arbitrary Detention  agreed that Assange has been arbitrarily held since his arrest in London in Dec. 7, 2010, over allegations of sex crimes. It called on the British and Swedish governments to end his “deprivation of liberty,” allow him to move freely and afford him the right to compensation for his suffering. He has always expressed a willingness to return to Sweden to address the charges which he denies, so long as assurances are given that any request for extradition by the US would be denied.

The UK threatened to revoke the Ecuadorian embassy’s status but they held firm. Under the previous Ecuadorian administration the following statement was released to explain why they had granted asylum to Julian Assange in 2012: “Publication of information about human rights abuses is a right in accordance with the Declaration on Human Rights Defenders of 1998, the exercise of which implies a right of protection to those who reveal such violations by honest journalism and the courageous whistleblowers who denounce human rights violations. We felt that the fate of Chelsea Manning, evidence of secret grand jury procedures and Snowden’s exile in Russia corroborate the fears Assange had for his security, freedom and life when he sought refuge in the Ecuadorian embassy in London more than two years ago.”

Whatever the outcome, we can hope that any future  decision by the Ecuadorian government will reflect human rights and not self interest. Assange’s lawyer, Melinda Taylor, said he is the “victim of a significant miscarriage of justice.”

 

PALESTINE MARCH OF RETURN

Following the British withdrawal from Palestine in 1948  the newly declared  State of Israel was accepted into the United Nations on condition that it accept the Right of Return of the Palestinian refugees. (Admission of Israel to membership in the United Nations General Assembly Resolution 273 of May 11, 1949 ) This requires Israel to comply with General Assembly Resolution 194 of December 11, 1948 to which Israel  agreed. Since then the world has watched warily, the inevitable outcome of a blatant and continuous ‘land grab’ of Palestinian ancestral homelands. Despite repeated international efforts, no provision has been made to repatriate the 80,000 Palestinians made homeless following Israeli occupation of disputed territories after the subsequent Arab/Israeli war of 1967. The continuous, illegal appropriation of land by a policy of Settlement building in the West Bank (proclaimed illegal by the United Nations) is accelerating. This is an effective method used by colonial powers world wide as a means of ousting indigenous populations to disavow them of land and property rights. Despite global condemnation and UN censure there has been no attempt to sanction Israel

The annual Palestine Land Day March 30th commemorates events in 1976 when Palestinians held marches and general strikes in response to the Israeli governments plan to expropriate lands in Galilee. Riots erupted and  were suppressed by the  Israeli  Defense Forces and police. Six Arab citizens were killed with around a hundred injured. More than forty years later the protests continue. In March 2018 Israeli soldiers fired tear gas and live ammunition killing 18 Palestinians and injuring more than 1,500.. 

Freedom is always bought at a price and too often in blood, for power is never relinquished voluntarily by those who wield it. Requests are never enough, demands are ineffective, only a refusal to comply with systems and regimes designed to crush the human spirit  can change the dynamic. When the slow fuse of civil disobedience is ignored for decades a militant response becomes the last resort.

Mahatma Ghandi’s warning that the right to self defence is imperative should be heeded. He demonstrated his ethic of non violence not in passivity but as an active opposition force through civil disobedience.  Ghandi helped recruit Indian soldiers in WW1, when asked whether violence was ever  appropriate he stated that ‘we should have the ability to defend ourselves, that is, the ability to bear arms and to use them‘…. ‘But I believe that nonviolence is infinitely superior to violence’

Nelson Mandela, imprisoned for what today would be classified as terrorism, resorted  to violence in an effort to overthrow the oppressive South African regime and paid the price. In a week which marks the passing of Winnie Mandikizela – Mandela, his wife of 38 years, we have a stark reminder of how even the most courageous and determined freedom fighters  are irrevocably scarred by continuous humiliation, turning in desperation at times to violence. Winnie Mandela endured repeated imprisonment, torture and separation from her children and her people for refusing to submit to a vicious system of apartheid during her husbands 27 years of incarceration.  Her controversial actions did little to dim the light of Mandela but sadly diminished her role as Mother of the Nation.

In response to the militant stance of the Black Power movement following the Watts riots of 1965, Martin Luther King Jnr famously said: ‘A riot is the language of the unheard’.   He wrote: Cowardice asks the question – is it safe? Expediency asks the question – is it politic?
Vanity asks the question – is it popular?
But conscience asks the question – is it right?
And there comes a time when one must take a position
that is neither safe, nor politic, nor popular; but one must take it because it is right.    

Violence is an ultimate response to intransigence and the unwillingness to share power equitably. We do not have a Ghandi, a King or a Mandela in these troubled times. It would be expedient for Israel to acknowledge that for the Palestinian question ever to be resolved there must be a restoration of nationhood and land. As the occupying force, Israel holds the power position, it is therefore incumbent upon them to initiate change in what has become a war of attrition. Far from being diminished they would then be acting in accordance with the tenets of the religion which guides them.

See: Jerusalem – A pocket history for Trump

Jimmy Carter unveils truth about Israel (2009)

CARDINAL SIN – ‘Oh what a tangled web we weave when first we practice to deceive…’

‘criminal abuse,  denial, payoff and coverup that resonates around the world’.  Globe reporters eventually confirmed that 70 ‘out of court’ settlements had  been made previously which barred catholic victims and their families from ever talking. Even more shocking than the abuse by priests was that bishops and cardinals knew and engaged in a sustained cover up. ‘We had letters from parents, letters to and from priests and masses of internal church documents showing abusive priests being repeatedly moved rather than reported to the authorities.‘  Continue reading →

Pedophilia – When is a secret a secret?

AUSTRALIAN ROYAL COMMISSION ON CHILD ABUSE

Survivors accounts given to the Royal Commission  speak of the life long psychological  damage as a result of abuse by priests and the failure to make them accountable.Of all the survivors who reported abuse in religious institutions, more than 60 per cent said it had happened at the hands of the Catholic Church, the average age of abuse victims at Catholic institutions was 11 years old. The royal commission report said the Catholics had demonstrated “catastrophic failures of leadership”, particularly before the 1990s. The Commission   called for sweeping  legislative and policy changes, one of which would force priests to inform the police of anyone who confessed  to the sexual abuse of children, stating that there should be “no excuse, protection nor privilege” for clergy and  recommending that priests should face criminal charges for failing to report information heard during confession.

 Melbourne Archbishop Denis Hart president of the Australian Catholic Bishops Conference, has said he would  ‘rather  go to jail  than break the sanctity of the confessional.‘ The Confessional Seal prevents any Catholic priest disclosing information given in confidence in confession, it applies even to the most serious crimes including where someone admits to  the sexual abuse of children. The cardinal regards the Confessional Seal  ‘to be of higher importance than any legislation’ and explained:  “The penalty for any priest breaking the seal is excommunication, being cast out of the church, so it’s a real, serious, spiritual matter,” he said.. For whom, we might ask?  For few people could think of a more ‘real, serious spiritual matter’ than the sexual abuse of children.The cardinals comments follow the 2017 report by Australia’s Royal Commission into child sexual abuse. Continue reading →

Letter to Pope Francis – Contradicts his denial

Continue reading →

The Open Secret- Children of Priests

Updated July 2019

The number of children born to priests is unknown although one support group, Coping International, founded by the son of a priest, has 50,000 users in 175 countries. Some children are the result of consensual relationships, but others are the result of rape or abuse.   It is perhaps inevitable that Catholic priests, forced to suppress their sexuality would have been breaking their vows of celibacy and fathering children for centuries, through both abusive and loving relationships. The Vatican has kept the ‘open secret’ never addressing the question of responsibility for the emotional and financial support of these children and their mothers.In 2019 the Vatican has acknowledged for the first time the existence of secret guidelines for priests who break their vows of celibacy and father children.

After becoming aware of others in his position, Vincent Doyle, a committed Catholic, went to see papal nuncio Archbishop Charles Browne who arranged for him to have a front seat at a general audience in Rome with Pope Francis, on the anniversary of his father’s death.  He passed a letter in Spanish to the pope, similar to one already sent to Irish bishops concerning acknowledgement of children fathered by priests. On his return to Ireland he found Irish bishops supportive, noting the lack of guidance in Cannon Law, Archbishop Martin of Dublin, an outspoken supporter of clergy abuse survivors, took up his cause, along with other bishops and agreed to fund a website.   www.copinginternational.com    

Doyle decided to make a personal appeal to Pope Francis regarding the rights of the children of priests and travelled to Rome to join the thousands of Catholic faithful filling St. Peter’s Square, in the hope of speaking with Pope Francis. When the pope approached, he kissed the papal ring (image left) and introduced himself in Spanish, the native language of the pope, saying ‘I am the son of a Catholic priest in Ireland,’ He handed the pope a letter, Francis placed an arm around his shoulder as he read the first paragraph ‘with a deeply sincere look on his face,’ Doyle recalled. ‘Then he held the letter to his heart and said, ‘Si, si, I will read.’ The last thing I said to him was, ‘You have until Monday!’  Three years later, Doyle has yet to hear back from the Vatican or to receive a response to his letters, phone calls, and emails to American prelates.

The newly acknowledged Vatican document requests that a cleric who has fathered a child leaves the priesthood to ‘assume his responsibilities as a parent by devoting himself exclusively to the child.’ However, Monsignor Andrea Ripa, undersecretary in the Congregation for the Clergy at the Vatican, told The New York Times that the guidelines were more of a formality than an order. The Vatican  declined to make its advice public, saying it was an internal matter. The report comes about two weeks after Pope Francis acknowledged for the first time the rape and sexual abuse of nuns by priests and bishops inside the Catholic Church.

In direct response to Vincent Doyle’s campaigning, Irish bishops instituted a global model. They say: ‘The birth of a child brings into being a unique person with a mother and a father. The two parents have a fundamental right to make their own decisions regarding their care of the new born child’ ….. ‘A child’s wellbeing must be the first consideration of a priest father, and that he must “face up” to his personal, legal, moral, and financial responsibilities directed by his superiors.’ The principles were not announced or published.

Follow this series: Letters to Priests’

BLAMED, SHAMED AND SILENCED – SEXUAL ABUSE OF NUNS BY PRIESTS

Catholic Christian Brothers and Sexual Abuse

Hearing impairment is by its very nature not only disabling but isolating as communication is compromised. Prior to advances in technology many profoundly deaf children were also mute, unable to speak, making them among the most vulnerable in society. The idea that anyone might take advantage of this disability is repugnant however historical child abuse in its many forms has been perpetrated by a minority of staff in residential care settings. This  is increasingly being revealed as an international problem, a sad commentary on society as a whole.

See http://www.koreatimes.co.kr/www/news/nation/2011/10/113_96847.html

Saint Josephs School for the Deaf opened in Dublin Ireland in 1845, run by the Catholic Christian Brothers, a teaching Order known for its strict and sometimes harsh discipline. The school gained a reputation for a high standard of education and vocational skills training boys as cobblers and tailors as preparation for financial independence.  Language is the foundation of culture, historically used, knowingly or unknowingly as  a powerful tool of abuse.

ISL ( Irish Sign Language)  is believed to have developed at St. Josephs enhancing a rich cultural heritage. As advances in sign language progressed, the American system of sign language was introduced but resisted by the Christian Brothers. Boys continued to be taught ISL while girls with hearing impairment at the neighbouring St Mary’s school were taught American Sign Language. The two systems were entirely different making communication between boys and girls attending the two schools almost impossible. This deliberate segregation by language, minimised interaction and the possibility of intermarriage between deaf couples as at that time it was widely believed that deafness was inherited. The significance of gender equality here should not be overlooked.

Post war advances in technology facilitated Oralism, using lip reading, speech, and mimicking the mouth shapes and breathing patterns of speech instead of  sign language. In 1957 Oralism replaced signing which was banned almost overnight, extreme punishment was applied to children using signing. Prior to this the boys were taught as one integrated group, under this new system they  were separated according to their level of hearing  impairment. Three groups were formed, profoundly deaf, partially  deaf and children who had no speech ie deaf and mute. This segregation applied to all aspects of the school, meals, socialising and sports, a kind of apartheid which resulted in animosity and division. Boys who  could only sign were taught in a separate building and not allowed to mix with former classmates. This further segregation isolated boys who were all profoundly deaf and mute, unintentionally providing opportunities for pedophile priests and lay staff to gain access to the most vulnerable…those unable to speak.

A later Commission of Enquiry into abuse at St Josephs confirmed physical and sexual abuse had been perpetrated by a number of Christian Brothers and lay staff. The following testimonies provide a glimpse of prolonged and torturous sexual abuse.

“I would scream at nights, but everyone was deaf, so no one would hear me….  ‘It could be three or four times a week, then the next week nothing would happen, the following week it would start all over again, I’d say it went on for nearly seven years. He used to come to my bed at 1 or 2 in the morning, he always carried a torch and would shine it on me when I was asleep. He began by rubbing his hands over my body. One night, what he did to me…. I screamed… he had the torch in his right hand and he hit me with the torch. The next day I had a black eye, a few boys asked me how I got it… I had to say that I slipped in the toilet. I was always thinking to myself – What’s he going to do to me this week, maybe he’ll do the same as last week..maybe he’ll do something different..he might hurt me more’.  “I sleep with the lamp on because I’m afraid of the dark”

“Saint Josephs to me was like Auschwitz… like a prison camp…it was not a house of God..they were evil people… 5 years of abuse just because I’m deaf”:  ‘I’ll never forget the first time it happened.. A Christian Brother came up to me in the Play Hall, he said he had a letter from my mother..he told me to meet me in his bedroom upstairs. I went to his bedroom and he put me sitting on his knee. I remember him opening the letter and there was an old pink ten shilling note in it, he said I could keep it for sweets. Then he started reading the letter, I was wearing short trousers at the time and he put his hand up my trouser leg and started molesting me…Some of the brothers were good… there were an awful lot of them bad. I remember one night a Brother came into my dormitory drunk..put his hand under my blankets and molested me…there was a bad smell of drink often… I didn’t tell anyone because I was afraid.’  While I was still at school I tried to kill myself.. . It ruined my life… I left school and went home and I became an alcoholic….I tried to kill myself a second time but my brother caught me…it still plays upon my mind you see”

These Walls Can Talk: Documentary  https://vimeo.com/186336558 

Follow this series: ‘Letters to priests’

 

 

ALL ROADS LEAD TO ROME – Sexual abuse of disabled children by priests

As Pope Francis’ continues to defend the Bishop of Chile, long identified as covering up abuse by a fellow priest who was later found guilty by the Vatican, we might remember the famous quote: “All that is necessary for the forces of evil to triumph is for enough good men to remain silent”. The growing scandal of pedophile Catholic priests reveals the magnitude of institutionalised sexual abuse of children over decades, perhaps the greatest shock is the lengths to which the church hierarchy have gone to conceal and deny the abuse. Under the spotlight of the ‘Me Too’ movement, a pause to consider the survivors who do not have the privilege of a celebrity platform from which to speak…who did not in fact even have a voice to speak with…. those who were hearing impaired or mute.  In considering the depth of depravity of pedophile priests we need look no further than the Provolo Institute for the Deaf in Verono Italy and the filmed confession of Father Nicholas Corradi:

“I never screamed..I could not speak”   
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wFDqSuUOLR8   

Corradi worked in the Provolo Institute for deaf and mute children in Italy for many years and was one of several priests accused of sexual abuse by disabled children. When the church hierarchy failed to respond to their disclosures the children went public, naming their abusers. In 2012 (during the pontificate of Pope Benedict) The Congregation for the Defense of the Faith determined that Corradi had sexually abused deaf and mute children in Italy. The Vatican sanctioned four priests but Carradi went unpunished and relocated to Argentina where he  took up employment at the Argentine Antonio Provolo Institute for hearing impaired children. Continue reading →

ADDING INSULT TO INJURY

The world reels from the gutter language used by the President of the United States as he manages to insult  a quarter of the countries of the world, concerning his views on immigration policy.  His response to accusations of racism,  a thinly veiled excuse – ‘it’s not racism it’s a financial problem‘  reveals the billionaire businessman beneath the presidential facade. By comparison the dignified response of the people of Haiti and Africa to his derogatory description of their countries provides an example that he would do well to emulate.

The United States has historically led the world in terms of resettlement, admitting 84,995 refugees in the fiscal year ending in September 2016. In 2017 President Trump cut the refugee quota by 50%, a policy currently being challenged in the Federal Court. In 2017 only 42,000 refugees were resettled in America; Canada in contrast  resettled 30,000 refugees in 2016.  Continue reading →

Weapons for Peace?

The text message received by residents of The State of Hawaii  warning of a ballistic missile threat, confirmed as ‘This is not a test’,  sent thousands  rushing for cover and sending final messages to family and friends. Thirty eight interminable minutes later they were informed that ‘someone clicked the wrong button on a shift change’.  Most experts agree that human error is the most likely trigger for a nuclear engagement, an event to which the opposing side should be expected to respond. The awesome military power which now rests in the hands of leaders who have repeatedly demonstrated their instability coupled with the spectre of fallible technology raises risk factors exponentially.

The farewell speech of President Eisenhower, a former general,  as he prepared to hand over power to President Kennedy on January 17th 1961 was “a solemn moment in a decidedly unsolemn time’, He warned a nation “giddy with prosperity, infatuated with youth and glamour, and aiming increasingly for the easy life.’ to be vigilant of the potential rise of the military industrial complex and potential abuse of power. Continue reading →

GLOBAL WARMING ON PLANET TRUMP

‘Climate change and global warming  are two different phenomena, but are interlinked, and each affects the other. Climate change is change in the climate of a region. Global warming is the rise in average temperature of the Earth. Human interference is the common factor, which is accelerating both’

For the nomadic herders of Siberia, climate change is not an illusion a joke or a scam. Scientific data confirms that Russia is already warming at one and a half times the rate of other parts of the world, leaving  reindeer, Russia’s cattle of the Arctic regions, under threat from climate change. Nomadic reindeer herders living near the north-west coast of Siberia where the sea freezes nine months of the year state that  the snow is melting sooner, and faster than before.

 During the autumn period between 2006 and 2013 sea ice began to melt instead of thickening. Traditionally the Nenet nomads cross the frozen Ob River in November with their reindeer herds to set up camp in the southern forests. Higher temperatures are delaying the annual winter trek  until late December  when the ice is finally thick enough to cross the frozen river. Continue reading →

AID and ‘undue influence’

The dictionary definition of undue influence: “influence by which a person is induced to act otherwise than by their own free will or without adequate attention to the consequences.”

Guatemala with a weaker and more corrupt state and a more impoverished society than that of Mexico has a growing public debt. President Perez Molina is looking to Washington for military aid to support the Guatemalan army to root out corruption. Honduras has the world’s highest murder rate  and high levels of sexual violence despite a population of a little over 9 million. An estimated 1 million Hondurans reside in the United States, 600,000 of whom are believed to be undocumented; consequently, immigration issues are an important item on the bilateral agenda.

Micronesia: (A Federation of small island states, formerly a United Nations Trust Territory under U.S. administration until gaining independence in 1986.) The US will provide $100 million annually over the next 20 years. Guam – 210 sq. mi.; population 186,000 Guam is the largest single island in Micronesia. A territory of the United States and one of its primary military bases in the Pacific. Nauru : 8 sq. mi.; population 9,000. An independent nation; single island. The United States is a major financial contributor to international and regional organizations that assist Nauru, Palau – 177 sq. mi.; population 21,000  an archipelago  of over 300 islands, only 8 of which are inhabited.Palau is the largest recipient of aid per capita from the US, receiving more than $852 million over the last 15 yerars.

Marshall Islands – 70 sq. mi.; population 68,000. The United States conquered the islands in 1944. The Marshall Islands served as a test theatre for American nuclear weapons from 1946 to 1958 with 67 weapon tests  conducted, These including the 15-megaton  hydrogen bomb test  on Bikini Atoll which was 1,000 times more powerful than the bomb dropped on Hiroshima, Bikini Atoll became uninhabitable. Prior to nuclear testing, the residents had initially accepted resettlement voluntarily to Rongerik Atoll, believing that they would be able to return home within a short time. Rongerik Atoll could not produce enough food and the islanders starved and were again relocated. In 1970  islanders returned to the Bikini Island, advised it was now safe, until further testing revealed dangerous levels of strontium-90.    Today the Marshall Islands, relies on nominal access to U.S. based health agencies and is, like so many of the islands states of Micronesia, dependent upon US Aid  which represents a large percentage of the islands’ gross domestic product.

TOGO West Africa: Amid a diplomatic drive by Israel to extend its influence in West Africa, Togolese President Faure Essozimna Gnassingbe  met Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu twice in 2017. This  included a conference hosted by the Togo President where Netanyahu stated “Israel is coming back to Africa, and Africa is coming back to Israel,” The President has visited Israel three times since 2012 and Lome the capital, consistently sides with Jerusalem in international organisations,”

While congratulating the moral victory of the 129 nations who chose to ignore the threat, at the UN Council we might also consider the 35 who chose to abstain and why, among them Canada for example, walking a political tightrope with one eye on current NAFTA negotiations.

AID: Which country gives the most?

If we measure per capita ie the amount of Aid divided by the income of the number of people in the donor country, the picture changes.  Europe and Scandinavia consistently giving most.The US, France, Japan and Canada fall off the list. Sweden moves from the mid range to first place and The United Arab Republic moves from the bottom to 2nd place, followed by Norway, Denmark and the Netherlands. Additional countries, Luxembourg, Switzerland, Turkey and Finland appear. Continue reading →

JERUSALEM: A Pocket History

‘A LAND FLOWING WITH MILK AND HONEY’

The original inhabitants of Jerusalem were Phoenician Canaanites, their culture is believed to have pioneered the Mediterranean system of agriculture, intensive horticulture, grain growing and commercial olive cultivation. Old Testament scripture states that the land is named after Canaan, a son of Ham, son of Noah, the ancestor of the Canaanite people. The Canaanites of the southern Levante worshipped a panoply of gods; the first known mention of the city of Jerusalem was in c. 2,000 BCE.

PHILISTIA  (present day Gaza on the Mediterranean coast of Israel) was the name of a region between Egypt and Canaan believed to be founded  c 2,100BC.  The Old Testament states that the inhabitants were Philistines. In Hebrew, Philistine literally means ‘of  Palestine’  (Phillistia). The name Jerusalem is of Canaanite origin, meaning “Founded by Shalem”:  Originally ‘Urushalim’ or ‘Urushalem’ the prefix uru means ‘founded by’, and the suffix salem or Shalem refers to the Canaanite ‘god of dusk, of the setting sun and of health and perfection’. The Sumero-Akkadian name for Jerusalem (1330 BCE) uru-salim, means “foundation of [or by] the god ‘Shalim‘ from Hebrew/Semitic meaning ‘to found, to lay a cornerstone’.

Though not a part of Canaan and never conquered by the Israelites, Phillistia was in the area said to have been promised to the Israelites by their God. The two nations were initially on peaceful terms but eventually warred for centuries. Goliath the giant was the Philistine from Gath,  killed by David  the shepherd boy (later King of Israel) with a slingshot stone. Under the later Roman occupation of Judea, Phillistia was renamed Palaestina,  the name Palestine and the Arab word Filistin originate from the Romanised Palaestina

According to the Old Testament  Abraham, the patriarch of Judaism, was born  in 1,813 BCE, he was a native of Ur of the Chaldeans, in Mesopotamia, now south eastern Iraq. Led by God Abraham settled in Haran, The Jewish Torah traces his  lineage through his twelve sons who became the ancestors of the twelve  tribes of Israel and his grandson Jacob.

The name Israel comes from the renaming of Jacob by the Hebrew god of the bible, following a heroic struggle when he wrestled with an angel. The Hebrew bible states the name is derived from ‘yisra’ meaning ‘to prevail over’ and ‘el ‘referring to ‘God, the divine’. Joseph the son of Jacob was sold into slavery in Egypt by his brothers but rose to prominence when he interpreted the dream of the pharaoh which predicted a famine in Egypt. Following the famine Jacob’s descendants, the Hebrews migrated to Egypt and under the patronage of Joseph, established a thriving community. After Joseph’s death the Hebrews were viewed as a threat to the indigenous population and were enslaved in Egypt for 400 years.

Directed by God, Moses led the Hebrew slaves to freedom through the Sinai Peninsula to Canaan, the ‘land flowing with milk and honey’  as promised  to them by their God. Canaan had an indigenous population of both settled and nomadic groups; the Israelites were commanded  by their god to conquer Canaan. The  conquest occurred under Joshua in c.1,406BC. The  Book of Joshua states that Canaanites are included in a list of nations to exterminate and later described as a group which the Israelites had annihilated. (Today this has been equated with genocide.) The land was divided between the 12 tribes, the sons of Jacob but the tribes were divided and warred against each other for centuries.

According to the Bible, the Israelite history of the city of Jerusalem began c.1,000 BCE when the city  was sacked by King David  (a descendant of the tribe of Judah) who later united the 12 tribes of Israel. Solomon, his son, built the Temple of Jerusalem, after the death of Solomon the kingdom became fragmented and was split into two parts, 10 tribes of Israel and 2 of Judah. The city of Jerusalem was located in Judah.

In the Assyrian conquest (740 BCE) the tribes of Israel were taken captive and exiled. They never returned to their homeland and are referred to as ‘the Ten lost tribes of Israel’ who became  scattered over centuries in the global  diaspora. The tribes of Judah (Jews) were exiled in the Babylonian conquest  (587/6 BCE). After the Fall of Babylon to the Persians in 539BCE Cyrus the Great issued a decree allowing the right of return of the Jewish tribes to Israel to rebuild their temple in Jerusalem. Some 50,000 returned  in 4 waves, the temple was dedicated in 516 BCE. Many of the exiles did not return to their homeland, most remained in Babylon or travelled westward and northward settling in what is now northern Israel, Lebanon and Syria.

The land which would in time become Israel was for centuries part of the Turkish-ruled Ottoman Empire. After World War One and the collapse of the Ottoman empire, the territory known as Palestine was  assigned by the victorious allied powers to Britain to administer under Mandate. This included land west of the River Jordan known by the Jews as the land of Israel. The terms of the mandate entrusted Britain with establishing  “a national home for the Jewish people” in Palestine so long as doing so did not prejudice the civil and religious rights of non-Jewish communities there.  In 1947 the United Nations, proposed partitioning Palestine into two states – one Jewish, one Arab – with the Jerusalem-Bethlehem area to become an international city. A few days before the British mandate was due to expire in 1948  the World Zionist Organization declared the Establishment of the State of Israel.

BALFOUR DECLARATION – ‘Freedom is never gained by the oppression of others’

 

 

PALESTINE – HUMAN RIGHTS AND PAPER TIGERS

ON THE 72nd ANNIVERSARY OF NAKBA DAY (15th May)  PALESTINIAN PROTESTS WERE CANCELLED DUE TO THE COVID1- PANDEMIC. PALESTINIANS  RESORTED TO SOCIAL MEDIA TO  REMIND THE WORLD OF THE ETHNIC CLEANSING OF 1948 AND THEIR CONTINUED FIGHT FOR A RETURN TO THEIR HOMELAND.

NAKBA DAY  (The Day of Catastrophe) marks the anniversary of the day hundreds of thousands of Palestinians were ethnically cleansed, forcibly evicted from their homes by Zionist paramilitaries, ushering in the declaration of the State of Israel. (Zionism is a political and not a religious movement). The event triggered an attack on Israel by adjacent Arab States. Of the thousands of Palestinians  who  were scattered across refugee camps in the occupied West Bank, the Gaza Strip, and Palestine’s neighbouring countries, most never returned home. Now, over five million Palestinian refugees are estimated to be still displaced.

ISRAELI COMMENT: “A Jewish state would not have come into being without the uprooting of 700,000 Palestinians. Therefore it was necessary to uproot them. There was no choice but to expel that population. It was necessary to cleanse the hinterland and cleanse the border areas and cleanse the main roads. It was necessary to cleanse the villages from which our convoys and our settlements were fired on” ….. Even the great American democracy could not have been created without the annihilation of the Indians.” Benny Morris: Israeli professor and historian.

IN THE SAME YEARS THE UNITED NATIONS GENERAL ASSEMBLY ADOPTED THE UNIVERSAL DECLARATION OF HUMAN RIGHTS.

It states: “Whereas recognition of the inherent dignity and of the equal and inalienable rights of all members of the human family is the foundation of freedom, justice and peace in the world,….. it is essential, if man is not to be compelled to have recourse, as a last resort, to rebellion against tyranny and oppression, that human rights should be protected by the rule of law,”  Article 1.
 All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights. They are endowed with reason and conscience and should act towards one another in a spirit of brotherhood.

Article 2.
 Everyone is entitled to all the rights and freedoms set forth in this Declaration, without distinction of any kind, such as race, colour, sex, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, property, birth or other status. Furthermore, no distinction shall be made on the basis of the political, jurisdictional or international status of the country or territory to which a person belongs, whether it be independent, trust, non-self-governing or under any other limitation of sovereignty.

The 1967 6 day Arab-Israeli War followed a supposed rise of Arab unification and a further failed attempt to restore Palestinian lands. This resulted in the occupation  by Israel of The Golan Heights, The Sinai Peninsula and the Gaza Strip. The  United Nations Security Council Resolution 242   called for “the establishment of a just and lasting peace in the Middle East” to be achieved by “the application of both the following principles: … Withdrawal of Israeli armed forces from territories occupied in the recent conflict … Termination of all claims or states of belligerency and respect for the right of every state in the area to live in peace within secure and recognized boundaries.” Part of the Golan Heights and the Sinai Peninsula were ceded in the Camp David Peace Accord between Egypt and Israel  in 1978, leaving the West  Bank and Gaza Strip under Israeli occupation.

 

Israel  prefers the term  ‘disputed territories’ denying its occupation.  The United Nations, Human Rights Watch and many other international bodies consider Israel to be the occupying power as it controls Gaza Strip’s airspace, territorial waters and  the movement of people or goods in or out of Gaza by air or sea.  Gaza remains one of the most densely populated places on Earth with a total area of 365 km, a population of over 1.7 million and eight over-crowded, under-resourced refugee camps. Its economy is at a standstill, half of its children are malnourished and people do not have  access to adequate medical care.

The Israeli occupation of Palestine is the longest military occupation in modern history.  Israeli illegal blockades, indiscriminate bombing, torture and imprisonment without trial are considered by many as war crimes. Palestinians continue to live in the shadow of the wall erected by Israel with restricted access to their holy shrines.

Today Israeli settlements  which have been declared  illegal by the impotent United Nations continue the policy of land dispossession.

See also: Hebrew v Arabic: Language as a Tool of Oppression

SYRIA AND THE GOLAN HEIGHTS – A Pocket History for Trump)

 

DAKOTA PIPELINE

‘You were here long before any of us were here…You are special people” …. the words used by President Donald Trump while honouring Native American veterans of WW2.  The irony of standing before a portrait of President Andrew Jackson was noted by many. Known for his harsh treatment of Native Americans, Jackson signed The Indian Removal Act which resulted in the deaths of thousands of native people forced to relocate. However, since native peoples remain disenfranchised today which Presidents portrait would have been appropriate?

The ‘code talkers’ used their  languages including Navajo, Choctaw, and Seminole to transmit sensitive military plans that US enemies could not translate.  By his words President Trump acknowledged the pre-eminence of indigenous native peoples: History has shown that this does not extend to their land rights including the current Dakota Access Pipeline. Construction sites are technically just north of the Sioux tribe’s reservation,  the Sioux say the government took this land from them illegally in an 1868 treaty.  They also accuse the government of approving the current pipeline construction without consulting them, a breach of US law and argue that the project would contaminate drinking water and damage sacred burial sites. Continue reading →

LINES IN THE SAND – Who created the Middle East?

WARS ARE DRIVEN BY CONQUEST AND PLUNDER – RESOURCES ARE ESSENTIAL TO THE SURVIVAL OF EMPIRES AND MILITARY MIGHT IS ESSENTIAL TO ACHIEVE ACCESS AND OCCUPATION

It was implied that this would include all of Mesopotamia, most of Syria and those parts of the peninsula of Arabia not already governed as British protectorates. This ignored an existing British alliance in central Arabia with Abdul-Aziz Ibn Saud, the Emir of Riyad, a leader of the militant Wahhabi Islamic movement who with British support ultimately became King Saud of Saudi Arabia, and a controversial ally of the West. Continue reading →

BALFOUR DECLARATION – ‘Freedom is never gained by the oppression of others’

The Balfour Declaration has been referred to as “made by a European power … about a non-European territory … in a flat disregard of both the presence and wishes of the native majority resident in that territory”.

The Balfour Declaration grew out of British self interest during ever changing fortunes of WW1. Control over Palestine was of strategic Imperial significance in order to keep Egypt and the Suez Canal within Britain’s sphere of influence. In essence, the Balfour Declaration,  promised the powerful Zionist Jewish political movement in Britain a homeland for the Jewish people in return for global Jewish support of their goal. The British Foreign Secretary handed the letter  to Baron Rothschild, an international financier, banker and Zionist sympathiser who acted as intermediary for the Zionist movement.

Continue reading →

‘The Art of the Deal’ ?

The Torah counsels: “Do not taunt your neighbour with the blemish you yourself have’.  

A return to diplomatic language as opposed to President Trump and Kim Jong-Un trading schoolyard insults, with each leader calling the other ‘little rocket man’ or ‘ a mentally deranged dotard’ would do much to reassure the people of the world who watch the stalemate with increasing apprehension.

Negotiation is the true art of the deal. ‘Negotiation’ is defined as ‘To reach an agreement or compromise by discussion’ three words it might be said which seem conspicuously absent from President Trumps vocabulary. As the self proclaimed ultimate deal maker Donald Trumps business success can not be disputed. The billionaire tycoon has frequently stated that success depends upon ‘knowing when to walk away from the table’. This does not necessarily equate with negotiating skills, for an unassailable power position makes for a table which is tilted in favour of one party, at best, manipulation, at worst, thinly veiled bullying. While a ruthless approach to business competitors can prove successful in commerce, ‘cutting a deal’ to ones own advantage in the global political arena, only fuels frustration and resentment as history shows us.

Negotiation does not begin with an ultimatum: ‘a final demand or statement of terms, the rejection of which will result in retaliation or a breakdown in relations’. This can only ever result in non cooperation and inevitably escalation of conflict. There must be something on the table to the advantage of both parties. In true negotiation each party contributes something to encourage trust, the first step being a pause, an agreement by both sides to halt behaviour seen as inflammatory or aggressive. In the case of the proposed denuclearisation of the Asian peninsula it has been suggested  by some that as a first step North Korea might pause its nuclear programme and the US  defer its training exercises in the South China Seas.

The idea that there can be a military solution to the current situation only confirms how little has been learned from the past and perhaps more importantly how little regard there is for human life. At present we do not even have ‘a table’ the forum which would enable both parties to meet. With both leaders diametrically opposed this is their ultimate test since neither can win without compromise. A wrong choice by either could  result in the death of millions of people, potentially triggering a world wide conflagration. Kim Jong Un faced with the unassailable military might of the US fortified by nuclear options, demands the right for North Korea to become a nuclear power. Rightly or wrongly he perceives an abuse of power ie being bullied to the table to bring about the objective already decided as a ‘done deal’ by the US. This is an opportunity for President Trump to demonstrate that true power, ‘the capacity or ability to direct or influence the behaviour of others or the course of events’ is exemplified when it is not used as coercion.

“Power is of two kinds. One is obtained by the fear of punishment and the other by acts of love. Power based on love is a thousand times more effective and permanent then the one derived from fear of punishment.”      Mahatma Ghandi

While we may be some way from feeling love for Kim Jong-un, love in its purest form is based in compassion, we can only hope this extends to all people of all nations.

(Errattum: Earlier correction-name of  Kim Jon-un)

‘Gunpowder, Treason and Plot’

Every 5th November the skies over the UK are illuminated by firework displays as Brits light their bonfires and burn effigies of Guy Fawkes, put to death 400 years ago with his co conspirators for attempting to blow up the Houses of Parliament. What has become a secular celebration is rooted in the religous persecution of Catholics. The legacy remains in a very real sense today as religous prejudice directly affecting monarchy and high office. 

  •  Catholics are still barred from ascending the throne. If a monarch wished to convert to Catholicism it would be their duty to relinquish the throne  in favour of the non catholic next in line.
  • Boris Johnson was the first Catholic Prime Minister since 1558 (Tony Blair deferred his  conversion to Catholicism during his premiership)
  • No Catholic priest could become an MP until the law was repealed in 2001

A glance over the medieval shoulder reveals religious intolerance and a capacity for atrocity equalling anything seen today. When Henry Vlll, the English king, separated from the Church of Rome in 1534 to form the Church of England, Protestantism was forced upon the population and those who dissented were made to pay fines, thrown into prison, tortured  or killed. Henry was succeeded by his son Edward who strengthened Protestantism before his death at age 15.  His  Catholic sister Mary Tudor then inherited the throne and tried to reinstate Catholicism,  some 280 religous dissenters were burned at the stake during her reign. Mary was succeeded by Elizabeth 1st,  daughter of Henry and Anne Boleyn who  re-established Protestantism and the Church of England. She was excommunicated by the  pope and the Spanish Armada set sail to restore ‘the true religion’ at his behest. The Armada failed and centuries of division and religious persecution of Catholics followed.

Catholics were seen as potential traitors and required to deny their allegiance to the pope.The Jesuit priesthood entered the country on behalf of the papacy and laws were tightened.  In 1585, the “Act Against Jesuits, Seminary Priests and other suchlike Disobedient Persons” made it High Treason for a priest to reside anywhere in England or for anyone to hide or assist a priest. Harsh laws meant fines, imprisonment or forfeiture of property could be imposed on those who brought catholic artefacts into the country or sent their children abroad to catholic schools or seminaries. It was illegal for priests to say mass or for parishioners to attend and priests were forced to hide in ‘priest holes’ to escape capture as the catholic population became increasingly estranged. Elizabeth died childless in 1603 and was succeeded by James Vl King of Scotland, the son of Mary Queen of Scots, becoming James 1 of England.  The two Protestant kingdoms  became the United Kingdom in 1603, further alienating the Catholic minority. Continue reading →

CATALONIA – What happens when language, culture and tradition are suppressed?

Barcelona, a favourite tourist destination for millions is Catalonia’s capital city. Catalonia, an autonomous community of Spain has now declared independence from Spain with Direct rule being imposed within hours. With images of recent police response to the Referendum still fresh we wait to see how Madrid will choose to impose or restore its authority. With the democratically elected Catalan government already dissolved and the chief of police sacked the potential consequences are dire.

Of 43% of Catalans who voted, 90% voted for Independence. Why, when they know the possible consequences… economic sanctions, alienation, with the EU, Nato, the US and numerous other countries refusing to acknowledge their voice. A deepening of the existing divisions within their own community is inevitable since many Catalans understandably wish to remain part of Spain. Perhaps it is because the struggle for self determination  is eternal, for some, unquenchable…it is the same spirit that drives patriots to defend their right to speak their own language, educate their children in their respective traditions, dance their own dances and sing their own songs….

Whether this vote leads to greater autonomy, civil unrest or inspires other such groups to follow suit, time will tell. Meanwhile a glance at their history does much to remind us of why so many might chose to vote in this way. As so often,  geography influences outcome. Catalonia is located between the regions which became France and Spain. As such it has been invaded, conquered, assimilated and at times ceded.

 Spain is a consolidation of former kingdoms, a legacy of a Roman, Muslim and Christian past. Islamic Spain (711 – 1492) was a multi cultural mix of Muslims, Christians and Jews. The conquest of the last Muslim kingdom tied Catalonia politically to the fate of the new Spanish kingdom, a unification of Aragon and Castile through the marriage of Catholic monarchs. The  kingdoms of Aragon and Castile came into being in the 11th century AD  and eventually united in the Union of Aragon and Castile in 1469.

Each kingdom retained their own distinctive rights, Catalan language and culture flourished in this period and a complex political system was established based in the concept of a pact between the estates of the realm and the king. Laws had to be approved in the General Court of Catalonia which was  one of the first parliamentary bodies of Europe that banned royal power since 1283. 

In 1516 the monarchies were formally united into a single Monarchy of Spain (“Kingdom of the Spains”) Each kingdom conserved its political institutions and maintained its own courts, laws, public administration, and separate coinage of money. Philip V, the first Bourbon king of Spain, invaded Aragon with his army in 1707, centralizing power and making the former Crown of Aragon territories into provinces. The traditional Catalan political institutions and rights were removed and the Catalan language was replaced by Castilian.

Following the Spanish Coup of 1923  the Basque region and Catalonia wanted independence this was refused. The Spanish Civil War (1936 – 1939) was fought between the Nationalists and the Republicans, the Nationalists won, and Franco ruled Spain as a dictator for the next 36 years, until his death in 1975. Franco abolished Catalan  autonomy in 1938 and made every effort to suppress Catalan culture. He prohibited expressions of language, traditional dance and culture, and religious practice. Catalan names were prohibited and replaced by Castilian equivalents with street names changed. Religious services were held in Castilian, and Castilian was the only language permitted to be used in public. Schools were banned from teaching Catalan. Few books were published in Catalan . Images of popular Catalan culture like the traditional Catalan dance, were also banned. Popular symbols of Catalan nationalism, such as statues, portraits, the flag, were all removed from public view.

The modern independence movement began when the 2006 Statute of Autonomy which had been agreed with the Spanish government and passed by a referendum in Catalonia, was challenged in the Spanish High Court of Justice which ruled that some of the articles were unconstitutional, or were to be interpreted restrictively. Popular protest against the decision quickly turned into demands for independence. With persistent demands, the Catalan Self Determination Referendum went ahead in 2014 with an 87%  YES vote of a 42% turnout.

 In a time of social and political upheaval  Catalonia has maintained peaceful protest. Is it timely to consider not only what has been gained but also what has been lost by progressive centralization of power. What is seen as the threat of fragmentation is perhaps in reality a yearning to restore identity and cohesion.

 

 

ROHINGYA ETHNIC CLEANSING – Who Benefits?

Image

 Myanmar (Burma) is located between India, China, Bangladesh and Thailand, its population is comprised of a distinct  ethnic mix of tribal peoples with 135 ethnic groups and ‘eight national races’.

‘The Rohingya people  are indigenous to Arakan, the old coastal country of Southeast Asia, now renamed Rakhine. In ancient times a  southern branch of the Silk Road connected India, Burma and China with Arakan  which became a key centre of maritime trade and cultural exchange for  Arab merchants. From the 8th century BC  Islamic conversion, intermarriage and settlement led to an  increased Muslim Arakan population. The modern day Rohingya believe they descended from  these early Muslim communities and ancient Sanskrit inscriptions in the region indicate that the founders of the first Arakanese states were Indian. As Muslims the Rohingya  are a minority religious group  in Myanmar where Buddhism is practiced by 88% of the population according to the latest government census. Minority groups dispute these figures. 

China is the original homeland of the Bamar  tribal people of the Dian Kingdom, annexed by China  in  109BCE.   The Bamar migrated from Central Asia and Tibet around the 9th century and settled in the region which is now northern Burma where they integrated with the native Pyu people. The Bamar people are primarily Buddhist and now comprise 69% of the total population of Myanmar. 

In 1784  the Bamar conquered Arakan, resulting in  some 35,000 Rohingya  fleeing  over a fifteen year period  into neighbouring  British Bengal, to seek protection. Thousands of men were executed by the Burmese military with many of the Arakan population deported to central Burma, leaving their homeland depopulated. The colonial policy of the British in India encouraged waves of Bengali migrants into the area of Arakan  to work as farm labourers, primarily due to the requirement for cheap labour to work in the paddy fields.

British commercial and strategic interest in Burma led to war in the mid-1820s. The  East India Company, an agent of British colonial power, extended its jurisdiction to Arakan, its armed forces seized the capital Rangoon, defeating the war-elephants and musketeers of the King of Ava. Arakan was annexed by the British in 1824 and administered as a colony by the East India Trading Company. Further wars led to Burmese defeat by the British Raj and the annexation of all of lower Burma in 1852. In 1885 following the British invasion of what was left of the Burmese kingdom the country’s ancient monarchy was abolished and its king exiled to India. Burma was then governed by the British Raj as a province of India, like the Punjab or Bengal, with little or no sensitivity to Burmese culture. As India moved towards independence, Rangoon became increasingly cosmopolitan with the Burmese becoming  an excluded minority. By the beginning of the 20th century, Indians were arriving in Burma at the rate of a quarter million per year, equivalent to the United Kingdom today taking 2 million people a year. By 1927, Rangoon exceeded New York City as the greatest immigration port in the world. Indian immigrants formed a majority of the population of the largest cities in Burma, fanning Burmese resentment, nationalism and religious hatred with riots specifically directed against the Indian Muslim community.

Colonial control was interrupted  by the Japanese invasion of Burma in 1942 when Arakan became prominent  in the conflict. The war resulted in a complete breakdown of civil governance in Burma  with  Buddhists instigating cruel measures against  Muslims. Allied forces were back in control by 1945 but the Burmese, already divided along ethnic and religious lines were impatient for Independence.The British were faced with an unexpected insurgency and thousands of Burmese nationalists fought and died in the guerilla warfare which followed before Burma became independent in 1948, by which time much of the country had been under British rule for nearly a hundred years. Arakan effectively became a colony of Burma.

Following a military coup in 1962  the military junta took power and promptly shut off the country from the outside world. Burma has only  emerged  from self-imposed isolation in recent years. The Rohingya have been systematically deprived of their political rights since that time. In 1982 New Citizenship law imposed by the military junta  excluded Rohingya from  the list of 135 national races, stripping them of citizenship.

In 1989 Burma was renamed Myanmar. Arakan State was renamed Rakhine State with identity cards excluding Rohingya. Formerly recognized as an indigenous ethnic nationality of Burma  with members of the group serving as representatives in the Burmese parliament and high-ranking government positions, the Rohingya are  now stateless, subjected to various forms of extortion and arbitrary taxation; land confiscation; forced eviction house destruction and financial restrictions on marriage. Rohingya  have been subjected to routine forced labour to work on military or government projects, arable land, has been confiscated by the military and given to Buddhist settlers.  In addition to political persecution in the last four years Rohingya Muslims have been  subjected  to escalating persecution by an extreme Buddhist  sect of monks. The UN describing Rohingya persecution as a crime against humanity.

Aung San Suu Kyi won the Nobel Peace prize for her peaceful resistance to oppression, suffering 15 years house arrest before leading the National League for Democracy to a major win in the first open election of 2015.  She has to date failed to speak for the Rohingya people and recently requested at the UN that the name Rohingya should not be used.

The international focus on Myanmar’s religious/ethnic issues has overshadowed the  vast land grabs by the government.The past two decades have seen a massive worldwide rise of corporate acquisitions of land for mining, timber, agriculture and water generated by military-economic interests.  Myanmar’s natural resources include oil and gas, various minerals, precious stones and gems, timber and forest products, hydropower potential, etc. Of these, natural gas, rubies, jade, and timber logs are the most valuable and currently provide a substantial portion of national income. In 2012 land  laws were changed to open the country to foreign investors. Corporate acquisitions were favoured and  land allocations increased by  170% between 2010 and 2013. Recently the government allocated 1,268,077 hectares (3,100,000 acres) in the Rohingya area of Myanmar for corporate rural development.

In the  Myanmar Census of  March 2014 the Burmese government banned the word “Rohingya”. It was reported that the  Myanmar government had created a plan to expel the country’s persecuted  Muslim minority. Under the proposal, all Rohingya who refuse to identify themselves as “Bengalis” (a term used for illegal migrants from Bangladesh) and do not have documentation acceptable to the government would be detained in camps before being driven out of the country. In 2016 the  UN accused Myanmar of ethnic cleansing of the Rohingya, estimating that a million Rohingya refugees will have left Myanmar for Bangladesh by the end of 2017.

Researchers from the International State Crime Initiative at Queen Mary University of London suggest that the Myanmar government is in the final stages of an organised process of genocide against the Rohingya.

Is Puerto Rico American?

Recent polls showed that 40% of Americans are unaware that Puerto Ricans are by law natural born citizens of the United States. 

Puerto Rico was originally populated by the  Taino Indians the indigenous people of the Caribbean, who originated in South America.. Christopher Columbus came ashore on November 19, 1493, carrying documentation from King Ferdinand of Spain and the Pope authorizing ‘any course of action necessary for the expansion of the Spanish Empire and the Christian faith’ and  claimed the island as a Spanish colony. Columbus renamed the island San Juan Bautista, in honour of St John the Baptist.The Spanish Crown offered free land as an incentive to those who wanted to populate the islands, on the condition that they swear their loyalty to the Spanish Crown with allegiance to the Roman Catholic Church.Despite decrees for the protection of the indigenous population, Taíno Indians were subjected to forced labour in the early years of colonization in addition to suffering extremely high fatalities from epidemics of European infectious  diseases from which they had no immunity. Continue reading →

JUST GEOGRAPHY!

TO BEGIN TO UNDERSTAND WHAT IS MEANT BY PEACE WE MUST FIRST UNDERSTAND WHAT IS MEANT BY WAR. 

  • Defence is the usual cloak worn to justify attack.
  • Wars are driven by conquest and plunder.
  • Resources are essential to the survival of empires,
  • Military might is essential to achieve access and occupation.

The invasion of Afghanistan presented as a war directed against the Taliban and Al Qaeda, to eliminate “Islamic terrorism” is now acknowledged as  a war of plunder to control resources. The objective – to sustain a geopolitical foothold in Central Asia and install western style ‘democracy’.Standing at the crossroads of pipeline routes and major oil and gas reserves, Afghanistan is a land bridge bordering on the former Soviet Union, China and Iran, it is acknowledged as a strategic hub in Central Asia, The invasion was a means to secure control  over the strategic trans-Afghan transport corridor which links the Caspian sea basin to the Arabian sea.

Adjacent Turkmenistan possesses the third largest natural gas reserves after Russia and Iran.Trans-Afghan oil and gas pipeline projects already contemplated include the $8.0 billion pipeline project which would transport Turkmenistan natural gas across Afghanistan, described as a “crucial transit corridor”. Just as the Iraqi war was about oil, the Afghan war is about control of oil and gas; Afghanistan is adjacent to countries which are rich in both.

In June 2010 The Pentagon  announcement of the vast scale of Afghanistan’s mineral wealth went largely unnoticed by the general public. The statement that this was  ‘recently discovered by a small team of Pentagon officials and American geologists’ is however refuted by the pre existing geological surveys conducted by the Soviet Union in the 1970s and early 1980s. These confirm prior knowledge by the  US  of the existence of not only huge untapped gas reserves but vast reserves of copper iron, high grade chrome ore, uranium, beryl, barite, lead, zinc, fluorspar, bauxite, lithium, tantalum, emeralds, gold and silver (Afghanistan, Mining Annual Review, The Mining Journal,  June, 1984).

To the east of Kabul vast deposits of Rubies, beryllium, emeralds, kunzite’s and gems that cannot be found anywhere else –stretch for hundreds of kilometres.

Afghanistan is a cornucopia of the minerals essential to modern industry including huge veins of iron, copper, cobalt and gold as well as rocks containing the rare metals beryllium, thorium, lithium and tantalum used in the air and spacecraft industries.

What has your mobile phone to do with the war in Afghanistan? “Lithium, an increasingly vital resource, is used in batteries for everything from mobile phones to laptops and BlackBerries and is key to the future of the electric car.” At present Chile, Australia, China and Argentina are the main suppliers of lithium to the world market with Bolivia and Chile the countries with the largest known reserves of lithium. The Pentagon confirm that lithium deposits in Afghanistan showed the potential to be as large as those of Bolivia”

The Geopolitical Game Plan: As multi national mining conglomerates fight to achieve a foothold in the new race for supremacy, deals are being done. China’s National Petroleum Corporation, in partnership with a company controlled by relatives of President Karzai, is now pumping oil from the Amu Darya field in the north. The investment consortium arranged by JP Morgan Chase is mining gold while another Chinese company is trying to develop a huge copper mine. Meanwhile Copper and gold contracts are being tendered with others pending…..

For now the trillion-dollar reservoir of natural resources remains embedded in the soil for which so many have fought and died, sadly not for the cause they believed. We can be assured that the competitive interests of Russia, Iran and China will be met by those of the US and the members of the Nato Alliance.

See also:

Regime change and Democracy

Sounds like a Plan

WAS IT ABOUT OIL?

 In a CNN interview of October 2015 former British Prime Minister Tony Blair angered many when he made a token acknowledgment of his ‘mistakes’ over the Iraq War admitting there were ‘elements of truth’ to the view that the invasion helped promote the rise of ISL as a global terrorist group.

Hans Blix who headed the U.N. inspections in Iraq at the time of the war  has said in his memoirs. “Today, I look again at the reasons why this terrible mistake — and violation of the U.N. charter — took place and explore if any lessons be drawn –

  • The war aimed to eliminate weapons of mass destruction, but there weren’t any.
  • The war aimed to eliminate Al Qaeda in Iraq, but the terrorist group didn’t exist in the country until after the invasion.
  • The war aimed to make Iraq a model democracy based on law, but it replaced tyranny with anarchy and led America to practices that violated the laws of war.
  • The war aimed to transform Iraq to a friendly base for U.S. troops capable to act, if needed, against Iran — but instead it gave Iran a new ally in Baghdad

So was it about Oil?  Iraq has the second largest proven oil reserves in the world; the domestic oil industry was fully nationalised and closed to Western oil companies in 1972 and the   four major oil companies based in the US and the UK were excluded from contracts. Following the invasion in 2003 and  a decade of war,  the industry was largely privatised and completely dominated by foreign firms. Iraq’s oil production increased by more than 40% over five years to 3 million barrels of oil a day but 80% of this was exported out of the country while Iraqis struggled to meet basic energy consumption needs. Basic services such as water and electricity remained luxuries, with a quarter of the population living in poverty.

Quotes

 “Of course it’s about oil; we can’t really deny that,” Gen. John Abizaid, Head of U.S. Central Command and Military Operations in Iraq, in 2007.,

“I am saddened that it is politically inconvenient to acknowledge what everyone knows: the Iraq war is largely about oil.”  Former Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan

“People say we’re not fighting for oil. Of course we are.” Former Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel 2007

Was it attempted genocide? In a paper for the Association of Genocide Scholars at the University of Manitoba, Professor Nagi of the School of Business at George Washington University cited a secret US Defence Intelligence Agency (DIA) document which he said amounted to “an early blueprint for genocide against the people of Iraq”. The DIA document revealed minute details of a fully workable method to ‘fully degrade the water treatment system’ of an entire nation” over a period of a decade. The sanctions policy would create “the conditions for widespread disease, including full scale epidemics,” thus “liquidating a significant portion of the population of Iraq”.

“Axis of Evil”… General Wesley Clark the former Supreme NATO Allied Commander and Joint Chiefs of Staff Director of Strategy and Policy, describes ((2003 – Winning Modern Wars) his conversation with a military officer in the Pentagon shortly after the 11 September attacks, regarding a plan to attack seven Middle Eastern countries in five years: “As I went back through the Pentagon in November 2001, one of the senior military staff officers had time for a chat. Yes, we were still on track for going against Iraq, he said. But there was more. This was being discussed as part of a five-year campaign plan, he said, and there were a total of seven countries, beginning with Iraq, then Syria, Lebanon, Libya, Iran, Somalia and Sudan. ,,,,,,,,  Deja vu!

See also:

Regime change and Democracy 

Just Geography!

 

 

POCKET HISTORY OF KOREA

Korea has suffered repeated invasion and occupation over the centuries, North Korea views American intentions as hostile and latest polls suggest that 94% of Americans view North Korea as a threat.. A glance at the history of the people  may assist us in gaining a better understanding of the ‘ paranoia’ which is often levelled at the country.

1894 Korea was a ‘protectorate’ of China when Japan forced the Chinese to sign a humiliating peace treaty which ostensibly gave Korea ‘full and complete independence and autonomy’. In fact this was a ploy, enabling Japan to gain a foothold on the peninsula, providing access to a supply of rich raw materials.

1905 Korea was forced to sign a ‘protectorate’ treaty’ with Japan designed to open up Korean ports to Japanese trade. Japanese citizens were granted territorial rights and the Japanese forced the abdication of the Emperor of Korea, replacing him with his son as a puppet.1910 Japan annexed Korea exploiting the Korean people throughout the brutal occupation. 1911 Cultural erosion: An Imperial Decree forced Koreans to surrender their family names and adopt Japanese names, the Korean language was prohibited. 1932 Land Dispossession: Korean land owners, unable to provide the documentation to prove ownership lost their land to Japanese settlers. Dispossessed Koreans were forced to become tenants and made to pay over half their crops as rent, this resulted in many Korean women being forced into factories or prostitution to pay taxes.

1945 Korea was liberated from Japanese occupation when Russia invaded and occupied North Korea and American forces moved into the south. The country was temporarily administered by the joint trusteeship of Russia and the US as allies, the intention being to grant independence after 5 years. As a result of the subsequent Cold War between Russia and America administration became contentious and the country was split into two parts to be administered separately.

1948 The two regions were divided at the 38th parallel, each with its own government. Both claimed to be the legitimate government and neither accepted the border as permanent.

 Kim Il Sung became the leader of North Korea from the division of the country, North Korea became a workers state with close alliance to the Soviet Union. South Korea was aligned to the US. 1950 North Korea invaded South Korea with the support of Stalin, the objective being unification, this is referred to by North Korea as the ‘Fatherland Liberation War’. A UN force came to the aid of South Korea, 88% of the military being American. North Korea was subject to a massive bombing campaign and China came to its defense with Russia providing ariel support. In China the war is called ‘The War to resist US aggression and aid Korea’.

1953 An Armistice ended the fighting but no peace treaty was ever signed, the two countries remain technically at war with the 38th parallel the boundary.1960s North Korea, supported by the USSR enjoyed a higher standard of living than South Korea, 1980s due to Japanese and American investment the economy of South Korea flourished. The collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991 resulted in a loss of economic aid, adversely affecting the economy of North Korea. Since that time China has been North Korea’s only major ally.

2017 All attempts to impose economic sanctions to stop North Korea acquiring nuclear weapons have so far failed. North Korea insists that a nuclear defense system is essential in view of America’s perceived hostile stance, the 35,000 US personnel stationed in South Korea and the tens of thousands of American troops deployed in bases in Japan, Guam and the Philippines.

The most successful Commanders in history have been forced to choose between governing options.  Accommodate  – Negotiate – Withdraw – Attack