Is Puerto Rico American?

Recent polls showed that 40% of Americans are unaware that Puerto Ricans are by law natural born citizens of the United States. 

Puerto Rico was originally populated by the  Taino Indians the indigenous people of the Caribbean, who originated in South America.. Christopher Columbus came ashore on November 19, 1493, carrying documentation from King Ferdinand of Spain and the Pope authorizing ‘any course of action necessary for the expansion of the Spanish Empire and the Christian faith’ and  claimed the island as a Spanish colony. Columbus renamed the island San Juan Bautista, in honour of St John the Baptist.The Spanish Crown offered free land as an incentive to those who wanted to populate the islands, on the condition that they swear their loyalty to the Spanish Crown with allegiance to the Roman Catholic Church.Despite decrees for the protection of the indigenous population, Taíno Indians were subjected to forced labour in the early years of colonization in addition to suffering extremely high fatalities from epidemics of European infectious  diseases from which they had no immunity.

Spanish colonial government transformed the island over the next 400 years with waves of African slaves brought to the island; the administration relying heavily on the industry of enslaved Africans and creoles for public works and defences, The distinctive Creole culture is a blend of indigenous Native American, African slaves and Spanish settlers, strongly influenced by the Iberian culture and language.  Later colonial invasions by the French, Dutch, and British further impacted the island and its people.

 By1890 the Caribbean islands offered strategic opportunities for the US in their plans to build a powerful navy and construct the Panama Canal for ease of access between the Atlantic and Pacific oceans. The acquisition of Caribbean colonies provided coaling and naval stations strengthening strategic points of defence. On July 25, 1898 the U.S. invaded Puerto Rico during the Spanish-American War resulting in Spain ceding its territories of Puerto Rico, Philippines and Guam, to the U.S. in effect bringing the Spanish Empire to an end.

The colonial relationship between United States and Puerto Rico began with military rule, with both governor and officials appointed by the President of the United States. In 1914, the Puerto Rican House of Delegates voted unanimously in favour of independence from the United States, but the vote was rejected by the U.S. Congress as “unconstitutional”. In 1917, the U.S. Congress passed the  Jones Act, which granted Puerto Ricans, born on or after, April 25, 1898, U.S. citizenship. All of the Puerto Rican House of Delegates voted unanimously against it stating that the US imposed citizenship in order to draft Puerto Rican men into the army with the advent of WW1. In 1948 a bill also known as the ‘Gag Law’ restrained the rights of the growing independence movements making itillegal to display a Puerto Rican flag, to sing a pro-independence tune, to talk of independence, or to campaign for independence. Under this law, it would be a crime to print, publish, sell, exhibit, organize or help anyone organize any society, group or assembly of people whose intentions are to paralyze or destroy the insular government. Anyone accused and found guilty of disobeying the law could be sentenced to ten years of prison, be fined $10,000 (US), or both. The US Congress repealed the law in  1957 as unconstitutional under the 1st Amendment. As American citizens living in a US Territory Puerto Ricans are disenfranchised, unable to vote for President or Vice Presidents in the United States Congress which governs them. In 1950, the U.S. Congress approved a democratic referendum   to determine the Puerto Rican Constitution.

The Special Committee on Decolonization was created in 1961 by the General Assembly of the United Nations with the purpose of ‘monitoring implementation of the Declaration on the Granting of Independence to Colonial Countries and Peoples and to make recommendations on its application.’ In 1978, the Special Committee determined that a “colonial relationship” existed between the US and Puerto Rica, a Caribbean nation. In   2012 a Puerta Rican Referendum  a majority (54% of those who voted) disagreed with “the present form of territorial status”. A further report of the UN Special Committee  in June 2016 called for the United States  ‘to expedite the process to allow the people of Puerto Rico to exercise fully their right to self-determination and independence, the aim being to enable them to take decisions in a sovereign manner, and to address their urgent economic and social needs, including unemployment, marginalization, insolvency and poverty”

In a plebiscite in 2017 to decide the preferred status of the Puerto Rican people only 23 percent voted, due to disputed terminology on ballot papers. Initially the options were for ‘Statehood’ or ‘Independence and Free Association with the US’.  President Trump intervened stating that a third choice of retaining the current status as a US Territory should be provided. ie Puerto Rico is a colony, subject to the plenary powers of the United States Congress. Under the ‘Independence/free association’ option, the ballot asserted that ‘Puerto Rico must be a sovereign nation in order to enter into a compact of free association with the United States’. Current status as an Unincorporated Territory could allow ‘sovereign status’ to be disputed, making any such vote null and void. Of the 23% minority vote 97 % voted in favour of Statehood. The vote is  non binding and must be approved by the US Congress.

Puerto Rico has been impoverished by its colonial past and by repeated natural disasters due to its geographical location. These include the major earthquake and tsunami of 1918 and the repeated  devastating hurricanes. While technically bankrupt, Puerto Rico remains legally barred from using Chapter 9, the bankruptcy route normally taken by insolvent local governments due to limitations as an Unincorporated Territory.  Unable to repay its $74 billion in bond debt and $49 billion in unfunded pension obligations, Puerto Rico appealed to the US for assistance in May 2017. President Trump responded on Twitter that there should be no “bailout” for Puerto Rico.The devastating hurricanes followed along with the controversy regarding the US response.  Former strategic advantages of colonial days must now be balanced by the costs incurred both fiscal and moral.  Donald Trump again tweeted “The fact is that Puerto Rico has been destroyed by two hurricanes. Big decisions will have to be made as to the cost of its rebuilding,” a possible clue!