CATALONIA – What happens when language, culture and tradition are suppressed?

Barcelona, a favourite tourist destination for millions is Catalonia’s capital city. Catalonia, an autonomous community of Spain has now declared independence from Spain with Direct rule being imposed within hours. With images of recent police response to the Referendum still fresh we wait to see how Madrid will choose to impose or restore its authority. With the democratically elected Catalan government already dissolved and the chief of police sacked the potential consequences are dire.

Of 43% of Catalans who voted, 90% voted for Independence. Why, when they know the possible consequences… economic sanctions, alienation, with the EU, Nato, the US and numerous other countries refusing to acknowledge their voice. A deepening of the existing divisions within their own community is inevitable since many Catalans understandably wish to remain part of Spain. Perhaps it is because the struggle for self determination  is eternal, for some, unquenchable…it is the same spirit that drives patriots to defend their right to speak their own language, educate their children in their respective traditions, dance their own dances and sing their own songs….

Whether this vote leads to greater autonomy, civil unrest or inspires other such groups to follow suit, time will tell. Meanwhile a glance at their history does much to remind us of why so many might chose to vote in this way. As so often,  geography influences outcome. Catalonia is located between the regions which became France and Spain. As such it has been invaded, conquered, assimilated and at times ceded.

 Spain is a consolidation of former kingdoms, a legacy of a Roman, Muslim and Christian past. Islamic Spain (711 – 1492) was a multi cultural mix of Muslims, Christians and Jews. The conquest of the last Muslim kingdom tied Catalonia politically to the fate of the new Spanish kingdom, a unification of Aragon and Castile through the marriage of Catholic monarchs. The  kingdoms of Aragon and Castile came into being in the 11th century AD  and eventually united in the Union of Aragon and Castile in 1469.

Each kingdom retained their own distinctive rights, Catalan language and culture flourished in this period and a complex political system was established based in the concept of a pact between the estates of the realm and the king. Laws had to be approved in the General Court of Catalonia which was  one of the first parliamentary bodies of Europe that banned royal power since 1283. 

In 1516 the monarchies were formally united into a single Monarchy of Spain (“Kingdom of the Spains”) Each kingdom conserved its political institutions and maintained its own courts, laws, public administration, and separate coinage of money. Philip V, the first Bourbon king of Spain, invaded Aragon with his army in 1707, centralizing power and making the former Crown of Aragon territories into provinces. The traditional Catalan political institutions and rights were removed and the Catalan language was replaced by Castilian.

Following the Spanish Coup of 1923  the Basque region and Catalonia wanted independence this was refused. The Spanish Civil War (1936 – 1939) was fought between the Nationalists and the Republicans, the Nationalists won, and Franco ruled Spain as a dictator for the next 36 years, until his death in 1975. Franco abolished Catalan  autonomy in 1938 and made every effort to suppress Catalan culture. He prohibited expressions of language, traditional dance and culture, and religious practice. Catalan names were prohibited and replaced by Castilian equivalents with street names changed. Religious services were held in Castilian, and Castilian was the only language permitted to be used in public. Schools were banned from teaching Catalan. Few books were published in Catalan . Images of popular Catalan culture like the traditional Catalan dance, were also banned. Popular symbols of Catalan nationalism, such as statues, portraits, the flag, were all removed from public view.

The modern independence movement began when the 2006 Statute of Autonomy which had been agreed with the Spanish government and passed by a referendum in Catalonia, was challenged in the Spanish High Court of Justice which ruled that some of the articles were unconstitutional, or were to be interpreted restrictively. Popular protest against the decision quickly turned into demands for independence. With persistent demands, the Catalan Self Determination Referendum went ahead in 2014 with an 87%  YES vote of a 42% turnout.

 In a time of social and political upheaval  Catalonia has maintained peaceful protest. Is it timely to consider not only what has been gained but also what has been lost by progressive centralization of power. What is seen as the threat of fragmentation is perhaps in reality a yearning to restore identity and cohesion.