CARDINAL SIN – ‘Oh what a tangled web we weave when first we practice to deceive…’

‘criminal abuse,  denial, payoff and coverup that resonates around the world’.  Globe reporters eventually confirmed that 70 ‘out of court’ settlements had  been made previously which barred catholic victims and their families from ever talking. Even more shocking than the abuse by priests was that bishops and cardinals knew and engaged in a sustained cover up. ‘We had letters from parents, letters to and from priests and masses of internal church documents showing abusive priests being repeatedly moved rather than reported to the authorities.‘  Continue reading →

Pedophilia – When is a secret a secret?

AUSTRALIAN ROYAL COMMISSION ON CHILD ABUSE

Survivors accounts given to the Royal Commission  speak of the life long psychological  damage as a result of abuse by priests and the failure to make them accountable.Of all the survivors who reported abuse in religious institutions, more than 60 per cent said it had happened at the hands of the Catholic Church, the average age of abuse victims at Catholic institutions was 11 years old. The royal commission report said the Catholics had demonstrated “catastrophic failures of leadership”, particularly before the 1990s. The Commission   called for sweeping  legislative and policy changes, one of which would force priests to inform the police of anyone who confessed  to the sexual abuse of children, stating that there should be “no excuse, protection nor privilege” for clergy and  recommending that priests should face criminal charges for failing to report information heard during confession.

 Melbourne Archbishop Denis Hart president of the Australian Catholic Bishops Conference, has said he would  ‘rather  go to jail  than break the sanctity of the confessional.‘ The Confessional Seal prevents any Catholic priest disclosing information given in confidence in confession, it applies even to the most serious crimes including where someone admits to  the sexual abuse of children. The cardinal regards the Confessional Seal  ‘to be of higher importance than any legislation’ and explained:  “The penalty for any priest breaking the seal is excommunication, being cast out of the church, so it’s a real, serious, spiritual matter,” he said.. For whom, we might ask?  For few people could think of a more ‘real, serious spiritual matter’ than the sexual abuse of children.The cardinals comments follow the 2017 report by Australia’s Royal Commission into child sexual abuse. Continue reading →

Letter to Pope Francis – Contradicts his denial

Continue reading →

The Open Secret- Children of Priests

Updated July 2019

The number of children born to priests is unknown although one support group, Coping International, founded by the son of a priest, has 50,000 users in 175 countries. Some children are the result of consensual relationships, but others are the result of rape or abuse.   It is perhaps inevitable that Catholic priests, forced to suppress their sexuality would have been breaking their vows of celibacy and fathering children for centuries, through both abusive and loving relationships. The Vatican has kept the ‘open secret’ never addressing the question of responsibility for the emotional and financial support of these children and their mothers.In 2019 the Vatican has acknowledged for the first time the existence of secret guidelines for priests who break their vows of celibacy and father children.

After becoming aware of others in his position, Vincent Doyle, a committed Catholic, went to see papal nuncio Archbishop Charles Browne who arranged for him to have a front seat at a general audience in Rome with Pope Francis, on the anniversary of his father’s death.  He passed a letter in Spanish to the pope, similar to one already sent to Irish bishops concerning acknowledgement of children fathered by priests. On his return to Ireland he found Irish bishops supportive, noting the lack of guidance in Cannon Law, Archbishop Martin of Dublin, an outspoken supporter of clergy abuse survivors, took up his cause, along with other bishops and agreed to fund a website.   www.copinginternational.com    

Doyle decided to make a personal appeal to Pope Francis regarding the rights of the children of priests and travelled to Rome to join the thousands of Catholic faithful filling St. Peter’s Square, in the hope of speaking with Pope Francis. When the pope approached, he kissed the papal ring (image left) and introduced himself in Spanish, the native language of the pope, saying ‘I am the son of a Catholic priest in Ireland,’ He handed the pope a letter, Francis placed an arm around his shoulder as he read the first paragraph ‘with a deeply sincere look on his face,’ Doyle recalled. ‘Then he held the letter to his heart and said, ‘Si, si, I will read.’ The last thing I said to him was, ‘You have until Monday!’  Three years later, Doyle has yet to hear back from the Vatican or to receive a response to his letters, phone calls, and emails to American prelates.

The newly acknowledged Vatican document requests that a cleric who has fathered a child leaves the priesthood to ‘assume his responsibilities as a parent by devoting himself exclusively to the child.’ However, Monsignor Andrea Ripa, undersecretary in the Congregation for the Clergy at the Vatican, told The New York Times that the guidelines were more of a formality than an order. The Vatican  declined to make its advice public, saying it was an internal matter. The report comes about two weeks after Pope Francis acknowledged for the first time the rape and sexual abuse of nuns by priests and bishops inside the Catholic Church.

In direct response to Vincent Doyle’s campaigning, Irish bishops instituted a global model. They say: ‘The birth of a child brings into being a unique person with a mother and a father. The two parents have a fundamental right to make their own decisions regarding their care of the new born child’ ….. ‘A child’s wellbeing must be the first consideration of a priest father, and that he must “face up” to his personal, legal, moral, and financial responsibilities directed by his superiors.’ The principles were not announced or published.

Follow this series: Letters to Priests’

BLAMED, SHAMED AND SILENCED – SEXUAL ABUSE OF NUNS BY PRIESTS

Catholic Christian Brothers and Sexual Abuse

Hearing impairment is by its very nature not only disabling but isolating as communication is compromised. Prior to advances in technology many profoundly deaf children were also mute, unable to speak, making them among the most vulnerable in society. The idea that anyone might take advantage of this disability is repugnant however historical child abuse in its many forms has been perpetrated by a minority of staff in residential care settings. This  is increasingly being revealed as an international problem, a sad commentary on society as a whole.

See http://www.koreatimes.co.kr/www/news/nation/2011/10/113_96847.html

Saint Josephs School for the Deaf opened in Dublin Ireland in 1845, run by the Catholic Christian Brothers, a teaching Order known for its strict and sometimes harsh discipline. The school gained a reputation for a high standard of education and vocational skills training boys as cobblers and tailors as preparation for financial independence.  Language is the foundation of culture, historically used, knowingly or unknowingly as  a powerful tool of abuse.

ISL ( Irish Sign Language)  is believed to have developed at St. Josephs enhancing a rich cultural heritage. As advances in sign language progressed, the American system of sign language was introduced but resisted by the Christian Brothers. Boys continued to be taught ISL while girls with hearing impairment at the neighbouring St Mary’s school were taught American Sign Language. The two systems were entirely different making communication between boys and girls attending the two schools almost impossible. This deliberate segregation by language, minimised interaction and the possibility of intermarriage between deaf couples as at that time it was widely believed that deafness was inherited. The significance of gender equality here should not be overlooked.

Post war advances in technology facilitated Oralism, using lip reading, speech, and mimicking the mouth shapes and breathing patterns of speech instead of  sign language. In 1957 Oralism replaced signing which was banned almost overnight, extreme punishment was applied to children using signing. Prior to this the boys were taught as one integrated group, under this new system they  were separated according to their level of hearing  impairment. Three groups were formed, profoundly deaf, partially  deaf and children who had no speech ie deaf and mute. This segregation applied to all aspects of the school, meals, socialising and sports, a kind of apartheid which resulted in animosity and division. Boys who  could only sign were taught in a separate building and not allowed to mix with former classmates. This further segregation isolated boys who were all profoundly deaf and mute, unintentionally providing opportunities for pedophile priests and lay staff to gain access to the most vulnerable…those unable to speak.

A later Commission of Enquiry into abuse at St Josephs confirmed physical and sexual abuse had been perpetrated by a number of Christian Brothers and lay staff. The following testimonies provide a glimpse of prolonged and torturous sexual abuse.

“I would scream at nights, but everyone was deaf, so no one would hear me….  ‘It could be three or four times a week, then the next week nothing would happen, the following week it would start all over again, I’d say it went on for nearly seven years. He used to come to my bed at 1 or 2 in the morning, he always carried a torch and would shine it on me when I was asleep. He began by rubbing his hands over my body. One night, what he did to me…. I screamed… he had the torch in his right hand and he hit me with the torch. The next day I had a black eye, a few boys asked me how I got it… I had to say that I slipped in the toilet. I was always thinking to myself – What’s he going to do to me this week, maybe he’ll do the same as last week..maybe he’ll do something different..he might hurt me more’.  “I sleep with the lamp on because I’m afraid of the dark”

“Saint Josephs to me was like Auschwitz… like a prison camp…it was not a house of God..they were evil people… 5 years of abuse just because I’m deaf”:  ‘I’ll never forget the first time it happened.. A Christian Brother came up to me in the Play Hall, he said he had a letter from my mother..he told me to meet me in his bedroom upstairs. I went to his bedroom and he put me sitting on his knee. I remember him opening the letter and there was an old pink ten shilling note in it, he said I could keep it for sweets. Then he started reading the letter, I was wearing short trousers at the time and he put his hand up my trouser leg and started molesting me…Some of the brothers were good… there were an awful lot of them bad. I remember one night a Brother came into my dormitory drunk..put his hand under my blankets and molested me…there was a bad smell of drink often… I didn’t tell anyone because I was afraid.’  While I was still at school I tried to kill myself.. . It ruined my life… I left school and went home and I became an alcoholic….I tried to kill myself a second time but my brother caught me…it still plays upon my mind you see”

These Walls Can Talk: Documentary  https://vimeo.com/186336558 

Follow this series: ‘Letters to priests’

 

 

ALL ROADS LEAD TO ROME – Sexual abuse of disabled children by priests

As Pope Francis’ continues to defend the Bishop of Chile, long identified as covering up abuse by a fellow priest who was later found guilty by the Vatican, we might remember the famous quote: “All that is necessary for the forces of evil to triumph is for enough good men to remain silent”. The growing scandal of pedophile Catholic priests reveals the magnitude of institutionalised sexual abuse of children over decades, perhaps the greatest shock is the lengths to which the church hierarchy have gone to conceal and deny the abuse. Under the spotlight of the ‘Me Too’ movement, a pause to consider the survivors who do not have the privilege of a celebrity platform from which to speak…who did not in fact even have a voice to speak with…. those who were hearing impaired or mute.  In considering the depth of depravity of pedophile priests we need look no further than the Provolo Institute for the Deaf in Verono Italy and the filmed confession of Father Nicholas Corradi:

“I never screamed..I could not speak”   
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wFDqSuUOLR8   

Corradi worked in the Provolo Institute for deaf and mute children in Italy for many years and was one of several priests accused of sexual abuse by disabled children. When the church hierarchy failed to respond to their disclosures the children went public, naming their abusers. In 2012 (during the pontificate of Pope Benedict) The Congregation for the Defense of the Faith determined that Corradi had sexually abused deaf and mute children in Italy. The Vatican sanctioned four priests but Carradi went unpunished and relocated to Argentina where he  took up employment at the Argentine Antonio Provolo Institute for hearing impaired children. Continue reading →

Money as Power

    ‘THE LOVE OF MONEY IS THE ROOT OF ALL EVIL”  Jesus Christ

Many might think that the wealth amassed by the Catholic Church is in conflict with the teachings of Jesus who advised his followers ‘If you have two shirts, give one to the man that has none’ and warned that ‘It is easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of heaven’.

WHERE DID THE WEALTH OF THE CHURCH ORIGINATE?

The medieval church amassed its fortune over centuries of supremacy over the European monarchies. In more recent times during the Unification of Italy the Catholic Church was deprived of its papal states which included Rome itself in addition to almost one third of the Italian peninsula. In order to a provide territorial  identity for the Holy See an agreement was made between the Kingdom of Italy represented by the fascist leader Benito Mussolini and Pope Pius XI. The Lateran Treaty of 1929 recognized the papal state under the name ‘Vatican City’ as a full sovereign independent  state an ecclesiastical monarchy ruled by the pope in which the highest offices of State are all held by Catholic clergy.

Through this treaty Italy agreed to pay the Vatican State $39million dollars in cash  and $52 million in 5% government bonds as indemnity for the loss incurred when the papal states were incorporated into  Italy in 1870. In 1942 the Vatican was exempted from certain taxes on dividends however in 1962 the government placed a tax on all stock dividends. The Vatican refused to pay, citing the Lateran Treaty and threatened to sell its Italian stocks and shares which would have caused a financial collapse of an already shaky market and the fall of the government. They remained exempt.

Power is dependent upon networks: The Holy See is a separate and distinct

Power is defined in many ways, not least by money.  ‘Vatican Billions’ written in the 1980s by the late Avro Manhattan, revealed the vast wealth and influence of the Catholic Church around the world. He described  “the biggest financial power, wealth accumulator and property owner in existence. She is a greater possessor of material riches than any other single institution, corporation, bank, giant trust, government or state of the whole globe.’ Renowned for the secrecy of its operation, with no oversight, the Vatican Bank has been worryingly described as the perfect money laundering system 

The Wall Street Journal has said that the Vatican’s financial deals in the U.S. alone are so big that very often it sold or bought gold in lots of a million or more dollars at one time. “The Vatican’s treasure of solid gold has been estimated by the United Nations World Magazine to amount to several billion dollars. A large bulk of this is stored in gold ingots with the U.S. Federal Reserve Bank, while banks in England and Switzerland hold the rest.’

“The Vatican has billions of shares in the most powerful international corporations… “In a statement published in connection with a bond prospectus, the Boston archdiocese listed its assets at Six Hundred and Thirty-five Million ($635,891,004), which is 9.9 times its liabilities. This leaves a net worth of Five Hundred and Seventy-one million dollars ($571,704,953). It is not difficult to discover the truly astonishing wealth of the church, once we add the riches of the twenty-eight archdioceses and 122 dioceses of the U.S.A., some of which are even wealthier than that of Boston.

The Cathedral of Our Lady of the Angels 
 is known to the local people as the Taj Mahony after their cardinal who had oversight of the project. It cost almost $200 million to build. The altar alone was said to have cost $5 million, the main bronze doors cost $3 million, $2 million was budgeted for the wooden lectern and $1 million for the tabernacle. $1 million was budgeted for the cathedra (bishop’s chair), $250,000 for the presider’s chair, $250,000 for each deacon’s chair, and $150,000 for each visiting bishops’ chair, while pews cost an average of $50,000 each. The budget presumably does not cover community outreach services which are not provided. Parishioners in need of  housing, food or money are obliged to use the neighbourhood parishes.

For a history of the papacy see: Jesus Chronicles – The Lost Teachings Published by Epiphany Press. Available through Amazon

 

 

EPIPHANY – An Astrological Interpretation

WHO WERE THE MAGI?

‘We three kings of Orient are, bearing gifts we traverse afar
Field and fountain, moor and mountain following yonder star’

A favourite carol tells of the three wise men who came to worship the child Jesus in the stable, a story retold for two thousand years.  Epiphany means ‘great light’ or ‘illumination’ referring in this instance to Jesus as the Light of the World. There are many interpretations of who these visitors might have been. They are variously described as Kings of the East and Astrologers and are commonly referred to as the Magi.  The word Magi means ‘wise ones’ and relates to those who had a deep knowledge of the divine sciences including astronomy, astrology, numerology and the study of the celestial heavens and ancient star maps.  Today’s term ‘magic’ is derived from it and used to describe something supernatural or beyond the ordinary.  Many intriguing questions arise.  If the story is true and the Magi did indeed come to pay homage to Jesus how did they know of his birth?  We are told they were guided by a star arising in the East which ‘went before them’ and finally ‘came to rest’ over the place where Jesus lay. Today Christians celebrate The Adoration of the Magi and the Feast of Epiphany on January 6th in remembrance of this event. If the Magi had ‘traversed afar’ from their own kingdoms, reputedly of the Persian Empire, this would have been a lengthy and even hazardous journey with much preparation required.  How could they possibly arrive within days of the birth…unless they had advance warning? Continue reading →