POPE FRANCIS – LOOKING THE OTHER WAY

“THE CATHOLIC CHURCH IS, AFTER THE CIRCLE OF FAMILY AND FRIENDS, THE ENVIRONMENT THAT HAS THE HIGHEST PREVALENCE OF SEXUAL VIOLENCE.                                                                           Inquiry into sexual abuse by French clergy.

Once again the Catholic church has lived up to its reputation for failing to protect the most vulnerable, refusing to report abusers and even knowingly placing children in contact with predators. France is reeling from the results of the report into child sexual abuse within the catholic church which revealed that 216,000 children were sexually abused over the past 70 years by 3,000 priests. The inquiry found the number of children abused in France could rise to 330,000, when taking into account abuses committed by lay members of the Church, such as teachers at Catholic schools.  

The head of the inquiry, Jean-Marc Sauvé stated “There has always been collusion between the church in France and the Vatican to protect perpetrators of abuse, the church is still in denial and shows contempt for the judicial process”.  Sauvé described the now familiar culture of negligence and cover up which concealed “deep, total and even cruel indifference” towards victims who sought justice. Internal disciplinary action was taken in only a handful of cases and criminal prosecutions were almost never brought; nine out of 10 people cannot get justice because the statute of limitations has passed or the perpetrator has died.

The 2,500 page report states the “vast majority” of victims were boys, many of them aged between 10 and 13 however nuns used crucifixes to rape little girls or forced boys to have sex with them. Two of those victims, Martine now 73, and Mireille, 71, were sexually assaulted by a priest when they were teenage girls in high school.  Martine commented “It brings on such terrible thoughts… For me, personally, I had to wait for my parents to die because otherwise  it was not possible to speak out.”

Marie was placed in a French Catholic boarding school, in the fifth grade. a nun would come to her class every day to choose a student to help her with Mass. “I was 11 and looked 9. She would choose me once every two or three times,” she recalls. “She would take me to her office, lock the door, and then draw the curtains. After which she would put me on her knees to make me read the gospel according to Saint Paul or another saint, while she squeezed me with one hand to her chest and pulled down my panties with the other hand. It terrified me and paralysed me.”  Persuaded by a friend to tell her parents, she was accused of lying and called a pervert. The abuse continued for a year.  “Marie” again told her mother about the abuse at the age of 35 but was still  not believed.

Archbishop Eric de Moulins-Beaufort, (elected president of the Bishops Conference in France in 2019) told the press of his determination to support survivors “so that the refusal to see, the refusal to hear, the desire to hide or mask the facts, the reluctance to denounce them publicly, disappears”   Days later in an interview he rejected the Commission’s recommendation to require priests to inform police of any child abuse cases learned about during the sacrament of confession stating that – “The secrecy of confession is a requirement and will remain a requirement – in a way, it is above the laws of the Republic. It creates a free space for speaking before God.”  This is in line with Vatican guidelines released last year when pope Francis reconfirmed that any crime, including child sexual abuse, discovered during confession cannot be revealed and remains subject to “the strictest bond of the sacramental seal”

The comments made by the pope regarding the French report have a hollow ring:  “I wish to express my sadness and pain to the victims for the trauma they have suffered and also our shame, my shame at the Church’s too long failure to place victims at the centre of its concerns”

IT IS NOT ENDLESS PLATITUDES, EXPRESSIONS OF SADNESS AND SHAME AND REQUESTS FOR FORGIVENESS THAT ARE NEEDED, IT IS ACTION. FIRST TO ENSURE CHILD PROTECTION IS IN PLACE AND SECOND TO PUNISH THE PERPETRATORS. THE POPE COULD START BY ENSURING THAT DISCLOSURES MADE DURING CONFESSION REQUIRE MANDATORY REPORTING TO THE POLICE.

While 80% of people in France are nominally Catholic church attendance has fallen to 10%, a reflection that the sexual abuse scandals of recent years depict systemic, institutional corruption. The pretence of reforming ecclesiastical structures and attempts to blame a few rogue priests is neither acceptable or believable. An acknowledgement of error followed by an acceptance of consequences is as true for the bishops and the pope as it is for paedophiles.

AND SO IT CONTINUES…

 Germany’s Catholic Church  commissioned an investigation into decades of child sex abuse by clergy covering the time period from 1946. When it was published in 2018 it detailed 3,677 victims who had been abused by  1,670 priests. 

THE GERMAN REPORT ALSO CONFIRMED HOW CATHOLIC NUNS  HAD PEDDLED ORPHAN BOYS TO PREDATORY PRIESTS AND PERVERTS FOR DECADES.

Two lawsuits allege that orphaned boys living in the boarding houses of the Order of the Sisters of the Divine Redeemer were sold or loaned for weeks at a time to perverts and pedophiles. The accusers state that as boys they were denied the opportunity of  adoption or fostering because selling them for rape brought income to the convent. Some of the boys were groomed to be sex slaves to perverts. The alleged abuse went on for years, with one of the males claiming the nuns even frequently visited their college dorms after they had left the convent. He said the nuns often drugged him and delivered him to predators’ apartments.

The report names various German businessmen and complicit clergy who “rented” the young boys from the nuns who ran a convent in Speyer, Germany during the 1960s and 1970s. Among the worst instances of abuse were orgies the young boys were forced to participate in before being returned to the convent where the nuns would then punish them for wrinkling their clothing or being covered in semen. The Order of Sisters of the Divine Redeemer did not answer multiple requests for comment about the allegations.

KARL HAUCKE,  63 YEAR OLD LEADER OF A VICTIM SUPPORT GROUP STATES THAT HE WAS ABUSED AT LEAST ONCE A WEEK BETWEEN THE AGES OF 11 AND 14, OFTEN BY MORE THAN ONE PRIEST.  HE WAS ALSO MADE TO RELATE HIS EXPERIENCES DURING WEEKLY CONFESSION  WHEN HIS ABUSER WOULD SAY “CONFESSION INCLUDES PENANCE… I’LL COME ROUND TO YOUR BED TONIGHT OR TOMORROW”

Survivors had demanded that Cardinal Reiner Maria Woelki, Archbishop of Cologne carry out an independent investigation, this was completed in January 2021 but the Archbishop  refused to release it stating that the report contained “inadmissible prejudices” against the Catholic church that were fed by scandals going on elsewhere.  The Archdiocese of Cologne will now release a revised and redacted edition. Archbishop Woelki’s attempts to silence the 560 page report  cited legal concerns that the perpetrators may have a right to privacy. This was  foiled when Haucke resigned from his victims committee post over the censoring and filed the law suit.

BISHOP KARL- HEINZ WIESMAN COMMENTED THE ABUSE REPORT WAS ‘SO GORY’ IT WAS TOO SHOCKING TO BE MADE PUBLIC. HE TOLD THE CATHOLIC NEWS AGENCY KNA THAT HE HAD TAKEN A MONTH’S SABBATICAL TO RECOVER AFTER READING IT, SAYING: “I HAVE LIMITED ENERGY FOR THE BURDENS I HAVE TO CARRY”

It is difficult to imagine that the bishop’s burdens were heavier to bear than that of the survivors. In March 2021 lawyers were allowed to release segments to news outlets.  Bjorn Gercke, a Munich attorney from the law firm which conducted the investigation presented the report describing “poisonous files” in reference to documents detailing evidence of abuse by priests and the attempted cover up of the crimes. Cardinal Woelki was accused of protecting priests suspected of sexual abuse.  Cardinal Joachim Meisner his predecessor who died in 2017, was found to have compiled many pages of evidence on members of the clergy  referred to as  “Brothers in the Mist,” a  term referencing abusive priests. 

On September 24th 2021, Pope Francis accused  Woelki of ‘grave errors’ but decided that he should remain as Cologne’s archbishop, a decision which shocked many. The Vatican statement announced that the cardinal retains the popes confidence and will take a sabbatical until Lent 2022. The Vatican has cleared two other auxiliary bishops of Cologne, Bishop Puff will resume his office immediately, Bishop Scwaderlapp will carry out his ministry in Mombassa for one year before resuming his work in Cologne.

See: Letterstopriests

Vatican Cover Up

November 2020: After two years, publication of the  Vatican internal investigation into former Cardinal McCarricks sexual abuse, has revealed a cover up by bishops, arch bishops and 3 popes.

By the 1990s, there was growing evidence pointing to Mc­Carrick’s misconduct: A handful of seminarians confided in a New Jersey bishop, describing how McCarrick would devise ways to share a bed with them involving explicit sexual activity. Anonymous letters were also sent to various prelates, including Cardinal John O’Connor of New York, warning of McCarricks  “proclivity for young boys.” O’Connor, in several sympathetic notes, alerted McCarrick, apologizing for sending the information saying: “This stuff drives me crazy but I would want you to do the same for me.” The Vatican’s then-ambassador to the United States then “destroyed” his copies of the letter.

Pope John Paul ll  not only knew about and overlooked sexual misconduct claims against McCarrick but promoted him. Although informed in writing that McCarrick shared a bed with young seminarians over whom he had authority, the pope chose to believe Mc Carricks written denials in a letter in which he stated that he  had never had “sexual relations with any person”.  McCarrick was then appointed arch bishop of Washington in 2001.

A  formidable church fundraiser,  McCarrick gave hundreds of thousands of dollars in church money to powerful Catholic clerics over nearly two decades, including those in the Vatican charged with assessing the misconduct claims against him. From 2001, McCarrick sent checks totalling more than $600,000 to clerics in Rome and elsewhere, including Vatican bureaucrats, papal advisers and two popes, according to church ledgers and former church officials. Several of the more than 100 recipients were directly involved in assessing misconduct claims against McCarrick. Meanwhile speculation continues, regarding McCarricks involvement in the $200 million Papal Foundation, which apparently served as a secret slush fund for corrupt Vatican enterprises, to the tune of tens of millions of dollars. Predictably, the report states there was no evidence “that Mc­Carrick’s customary gift-giving and donations impacted significant decisions made by the Holy See regarding McCarrick during any period.”

Archbishop Viganò, former Apostolic Nuncio to the United States, warned Pope Benedict in 2006, concerning McCarricks activities. The Vatican vacillated and no penalties were levied, instead “the decision was made to appeal to ­McCarrick’s conscience and ecclesial spirit,” requesting that he keep a low profile and reduce travel in the church’s name.  Benedict requested that McCarrick “spontaneously” withdraw as archbishop of Washington after he reached the standard retirement age of 75. McCarrick ignored the request  amassing power and prestige and travelling the world. In 2008 Vigano again wrote to Benedict and included a letter from Richard Sipe, a former monk and practising psychotherapist, specialising in clerical sexual abuse. Sipe confirmed that McCarrick’s activities “had been widely known for several decades.” In 2009 or 2010 according to Viganò, Pope Benedict XVI then placed severe restrictions on McCarrick’s movements and public ministry, not allowing him to travel beyond the grounds of the seminary where he was living and not permitting him to say Mass in public. Referred to as “one of a number of senior churchmen who were more or less put out to pasture during the eight-year pontificate of Benedict XVI,” he found himself put “back in the mix” with the election of Pope Francis in 2013.

In 2018 Archbishop Vigano stated publicly that Francis subsequently removed Benedict’s sanctions and made McCarrick “his trusted counsellor,” even though Francis “knew from at least June 23, 2013 that McCarrick was a serial predator. He knew that he was a corrupt man, he covered for him to the bitter end.” In May 2014, McCarrick travelled with Pope Francis to the Holy Land, to Armenia to discuss Syria with Eastern Orthodox clerics, the Philippines to visit typhoon victims, China for discussions on religious freedom, Iran for talks on nuclear proliferation and also served as a Vatican intermediary for the U.S.-Cuba talks. The  state-approved Chinese newspaper reported that McCarrick travelled to China in Feb. 2016 quoting McCarrick as saying that the similarities between Pope Francis and Xi Jinping could be “a special gift for the world.”

McCarrick was only officially removed from public ministry by Pope Francis in 2018, when the position of both became untenable due to credible allegations of abuse, dating back to the 1970s and acknowledgement by several diocese, of previous out of court settlements. These required claimants to agree to gag orders. McCarrick, was defrocked by Francis after Vatican officials found him guilty of two charges: “Soliciting sex during confession and committing “sins” with minors and adults… “with the aggravating factor of the abuse of power.” Pope Francis  ordered him to adopt a life of prayer and penance, he was provided with accommodation at a Capuchin Friary in Kansas with fees paid by the Catholic church. Following the failure of his Appeal, he relocated in 2020  to an undisclosed “secluded address away from public attention…to be closer to his family”.

THE LATEST INVESTIGATION INTO CLERICAL SEXUAL ABUSE  HAS THE POTENTIAL TO DAMAGE THE PUBLIC IMAGE OF THREE POPES, JOHN PAUL ll, NAMED A SAINT IN 2014, BENEDICT WHOSE DECISION MAKING IS CALLED INTO QUESTION AND THE MOTIVATION OF FRANCIS  IN THE REINSTATEMENT AND ELEVATION OF McCARRICK.

Predictably the report limits the culpability of Pope Francis, who instigated the investigation in 2018. The report states that Francis knew of rumours surrounding sexual conduct between McCarrick and adults but received no documentation of sexual impropriety until 2017 and was not aware of accusations of sexual abuse against minors until 2018. This is at odds with archbishop Viagno’s testament that Pope Francis removed sanctions and made McCarrick “his trusted counsellor,” even though Francis “knew from at least June 23, 2013 that McCarrick was a serial predator.”

Whichever may be true, responsibility for rectifying past errors surely rests with the appointed head of any organisation, government or in particular a church which claims its popes to be divinely appointed.

POST SCRIPT: A new lawsuit has been filed this year, alleging that McCerrick sexually molested an underage boy at a beach house on the New Jersey shore, that other priests groomed the young man and then introduced him to the bishop for sexual encounters at the property owned by the diocese of Metuchen. Jeff Anderson, the attorney for the plaintiff identified in court papers only as John Doe 14, said there were other boys who were abused, referring to “McCarrick’s sordid beach house child sex ring.”

For further details see:

Covering up the Cover Up – Cardinal Depravity

Bishps Aid Priests Instead of Victims