In Praise of Fathers

I WROTE TO JOHNNY DEPP DURING THE RECENT CASE HE BROUGHT AGAINST HIS EX WIFE AMBER HEARD WHO FALSELY ACCUSED HIM OF DOMESTIC ABUSE …I DID NOT WRITE TO THE ACTOR I WROTE TO THE FATHER.

This was  a letter of thanks for offering hope to the many fathers currently fighting false accusations of abuse in an attempt to see their children. Who could have believed that in the ‘Me Too’ climate, a jury would find Amber Heard’s claims of domestic abuse by her ex husband Johnny Depp to be false? So what made millions around the world watch the trial? Clearly this was much more than facile interest in one more celebrity show trial.

Perhaps the answer lies in comments made by Depp who gave his reasons for suing his ex wife, saying, “I wanted to stand up for my children  who had suffered bullying from their peers, taunting them that I was a wife beater”. Depp also said he was speaking up for men who do not have the advantage of his wealth to defend themselves in a court system biased against attempts by men to disprove false accusations made by former partners.

As a therapist of three decades working with actual victims of trauma and abuse, I have encountered many women attempting to come to terms with the enduring effects of domestic abuse. I am alternately inspired by their courage in seeking a better life and despairing at the long term damage. I saw them cowed, often for years, by the constant threat of violence, not daring to confront partners who were often well respected members of the local community. Complaints were rarely reported, it was accepted that they would not be believed, particularly by the police. I felt a strong commitment to the feminist movement and played my small part, training in counselling and psychotherapy working with adults and children, male and female, suffering the consequences of trauma of abuse.

Wrongful accusation is an abuse of power under the law,  when this is predicated as an accusation of physical and sexual abuse the consequences are far reaching, leaving an indelible scar. There are undoubtedly abusers who should forfeit their right to remain in contact with their families, however these instances are rare.  

A NEW PHENOMENA HAS EMERGED

Research indicates that a growing minority of women are choosing to make false accusations of abuse to gain Non Molestation Orders as in the case of Amber Heard. This is also reportedly being used by some mothers in an attempt to prevent or control access by fathers to their children following separation or divorce. It is therefore important to differentiate between fathers who are absent by choice and those who fight strenuously, often for years, in an effort to maintain contact with their children.

  • Legal Aid  in the UK was curtailed in 2013 due to austerity  leaving  many fathers unable to meet costly and lengthy court battles to fight for custody of their children.  An exception is made for applications related to domestic abuse and the granting of Non-Molestation Orders;  the exception does not however apply to the accused. In the year following its introduction, applications for LASPO (Legal Aid, Punishment and Sentencing of Offenders Act) boomed by 300%.  Prior to LASPO, the legal aid applications  were 40% men and  60% women, post-LASPO it is now 15% men and 85% women.
  • UK Family Courts have long been accused of bias towards mothers making it almost impossible for fathers to disprove wrongful accusation.
  • 200 children lose contact with their fathers every day in secret UK Family courts. Matt O’Connor, the founder of Fathers for Justice, the largest equal parenting campaign group in the world  has said: “If divorce is like a burning house then going into the family courts is like emptying a plane-load of napalm onto the situation.”
  • The US ManKind Initiative which supports victims of domestic violence, states that for every three sufferers of domestic abuse, one will be male. In 2015/16 13.6% of men stated they were victims of domestic violence.
  • In that same year, 28 men died at the hands of their partner or ex-partners, as compared with 77 women. These figures are underestimates since male victims (39%) are over three times more likely than women (12%) not to tell anyone about the partner abuse they are suffering from, due to social stigma.
  • Fathers are three times more likely to die following separation than mothers and separated fathers are at greater risk from depression and suicide.

The  ‘Me Too’ movement was able to raise awareness of domestic violence because strength lies in numbers.  I hoped that the daughters and grand daughters of previous generations would be the ones to bring about change, but watched as many became disenchanted with the endless stream of entitled, wealthy celebrities who displayed their anger and rage not only at perpetrators but increasingly at men, in their mistaken belief that all men are abusers. This stance is self defeating, for while anger may draw attention to a just cause it becomes wearying for those forced to listen to endless vitriol.

Although we may wish to believe otherwise, research shows that children who grow up in fatherless homes have a greater risk of major challenges in life than those who grow up with a father at home.

  • In the UK, 1 in 3 children (3.8 million) live without their fathers.
  • In the US, 1 in 4 children (19.5 million)  live without their fathers.

U.S. Department of Justice figures show that children from fatherless homes account for 63 percent of youth suicides, 90 percent of all homeless and runaway youths, 75 percent of adolescent patients in substance abuse centers and 85 percent of all children who exhibit behavioural disorders. Young men who grow up in homes without fathers are twice as likely to end up in jail as those who come from two-parent families.

Amber Heard used the mantle of ‘ME TOO’ to make false accusations against her former husband and almost destroyed him. He courageously fought back and in doing so gave voice to the men without a voice who are increasingly accused of domestic abuse of all kinds in an attempt to limit what is surely the most basic human right, contact with one’s own children.

  “Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere….

Whatever affects one directly, affects all indirectly”.

                                                                                      Martin Luther King

One thought on “In Praise of Fathers”

  1. In my view false allegations are much more common than the usual narrative. There are a multitude of reasons why that narrative is false. First perhaps, is that fundamentally, biologically and traditionally men are expendable. Men are, and have been cannon fodder for hundreds of years. The “women must be believed” mantra has also infected cognitive reality. The “men are perpetrators and women are victims” ideology has not only replaced proper fact finding by being elevated to the status of an entrenched presumption, even if the real facts are remarkably divulged then they are filtered through a distorted cognition. “Women must be believed” has at least 3 inescapable results (some feminists would gleefully say “benefits”): Innocent men are imprisoned, made childless and suicide. The solution is simply stated: women must be made accountable for false allegations.

Comments are closed.