Trouble in Paradise – A Pocket History of Hawai’i

Damage assessment  by the University of Hawai’i Pacific Disaster Center ( PDC ) and the Maui Emergency Management Agency dated August 11, 2023, estimate  $5.5 billion costs to rebuild following the recent disastrous fire. FEMA the financially stressed disaster agency which has been called on for numerous environmental catastrophes in recent years, is already facing a serious funding shortfall. Caught up in partisan politics in Washington it is expected to run out of money within the month.

The Biden administration sought $12 billion in emergency funding to extend disaster relief programmes while simultaneously requesting some $24.1 billion in military spending for Ukraine in the same package.

History of the islands: The island of Mauii is the second-largest in a chain of 8 islands, an archipelago in the Pacific Ocean. Native Hawaiian people are  Polynesian or Pacific Islanders who arrived in Hawai’i some 1500 years ago after navigating the ocean using only the stars to guide them.  In 1778 Captain James Cook, the British explorer, landed on the island of Kauai, becoming the first European to make contact with the Islands. From 1794 to 1795 the islands were controlled by Britain who helped King Kamehameha unite the Hawaiian kingdom into a single sovereign state. The islands were used as a trading base for sugar cane although the monarchy was left in place.

Hawai’i is located at an important strategic location between the US and Asia, 2,000 miles (3,200 km) from the US mainland. The islands provided a key provisioning spot for American whaling ships, bringing Protestant missionaries.  The US government saw an opportunity in colonising Hawai’i to enrich the American economy through a new commodity of sugar cane production which was attracting resident American and European capitalists and landholders who set up plantations.

The Kingdom of Hawai’i was officially a sovereign nation from 1810 – 1893.

    •  In 1843  the unofficial five-month occupation of the Hawaiian Islands by British captain Lord George Paulet was ended, encouraged by the arrival of American warships defending American interests. Britain reestablished the islands independence on July 31 1843 and withdrew, replaced by an American led government of landowners.
    • In 1874 the US government pressured a new ruler to surrender  Pearl Harbour to the US navy. King Kalākaua was concerned that this violated Hawaiian traditions that land is sacred and not for sale and would lead to annexation. In 1875 the US agreed to a temporary seven year lease but at the end of the term showed little interest in renewal  of limited access.
    • 1887: On January 20, 1887, the United States began leasing Pearl Harbor.  Shortly afterwards the Constitution of the Kingdom of Hawai’i was rewritten by American landowners (The Bayonet Constitution) and signed under duress by King Kalākaua, stripping the Hawaiian monarchy of much of its authority. Two thirds of native Hawaiian and Asian citizens were disenfranchised of the right to vote through restrictive property and land rights. Asaian immigrants were no longer able to aquire citizenship while Americans and Europeans could retain their home country citizenship and vote as citizens of Hawai’i  American citizens were allowed to hold elected office.
    • In 1889 a small scale rebellion prompted the landing of US marines. The  king died in 1891 and his sister Queen Liliʻuokalani took the throne. In 1893 she  was placed under house arrest in Honolulu  by American colonists, businessmen who controlled Hawai’i’s sugar-based economy.
    • In 1894  the Republic of Hawai’i was established when the sovereign Hawaiian kingdom was overthrown illegally by American landowners.
    • In 1897-1898  More than half of native Hawaiians declared their refusal to join the United States in the Kuʻe Petitions.
    • In 1898 the U.S. annexed Hawaii as a US Territory with the agreement of the mostly American elite. Hawai’i lost its independence, and much of its culture, unwillingly becoming a United States territory.
    • On August 21st 1959 Hawai’i became athe 50th US State.
  • The former queen deposed by the U.S. military, travelled to Washington D.C. several times to plead for the rights of Native Hawaiians and for the fair settlement of Crown lands. Annexation had a devastating effect on the Hawaiian population effectively making them strangers in their own country. The native Hawaiian population was suplanted by the larger population of foreign immigrants due to a growing demand for labour on the Hawaiian sugar cane and pineapple plantations. The import of foreign workers started in the 1850s with workers coming from China, Japan, the Philippines, Korea, Germany, Portugal, Norway, Spain, Scotland, Puerto Rico and Russia.

In the most recent Census 690,000 people reported that they were Native Hawaiian or of a mixed-race including Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander. There may now be as few as 5,000 pure-blood Native Hawaiians remaining in the world.

As a result of American Imperialism the cultural identity of a diminishing population was eroded. Traditional Hula, originally the sacred dance honouring the movement of wind and waves, was commercialised and sexualised to meet commercial appetites.

Hawaiian children were not allowed to attend high school unless they adhered to the Americanisation policy and therefore entered the work force disadvantaged.

The Hawaiian language had been banned from school instruction in 1896. From then on, in almost all public spaces, English quickly replaced Hawaiian, reminiscent of the experience of Native Americans on the mainland who were forbidden to speak their own language under a programme of assimilation. Generations of families know of their elders being beaten in school for speaking Hawaiian, the language would not be heard in schools for the next four generations.The number of Hawaiian speakers plummeted from 40,000 in 1896 to 2,000 in 1978. UNESCO classifies Hawaiian as  “critically endangered.” However, language preservation initiatives are helping the language make a comeback.

    • In 1901 Congress approved the acquisition of lands for the development of a naval station at Pearl Harbor under the land Appropriation Act. The owners of the property refused to accept what was deemed to be a fair price and Condemnation proceedings under the Hawaiian law of eminent domain, were begun on 6 July 1901. In 1908, the Pearl Harbor Naval Shipyard was established.

Pearl Harbor has been the headquarters of the United States Pacific Fleet since 1940.

Ecology: In the late 18th century, Lahaina, Maui, carried such an abundance of water that early explorers reportedly anointed it “Venice of the Pacific”. Natural wetlands nourished breadfruit trees, extensive taro terraces and fishponds that sustained wildlife and generations of Native Hawaiian families. But more than a century and a half of plantation agriculture, driven by American and European colonists, have depleted streams and turned biodiverse food forests into tinderboxes. The extensive use of pesticides on Maui’s pineapple fields poisoned nearby water wells. Experts say the altered ecology gave rise to the August blaze that decimated the historic west Maui town and killed more than 111 people.

In the 1980s pineapple production declined as Dole and Del Monte relocated much of their plantation acreage elsewhere in the world, primarily due to high U.S. labour and land costs. Dole closed down the entirety of its Lanai pineapple operations in 1992, while Del Monte harvested its final Hawai’i crop in 2008 leaving hundreds without employment.

Today Hawai’i has one of the highest rates of homelessness per capita in the US. Of the 4,448 people facing homelessness on the island of Oahu, 51% identified as Native Hawaiian/Pacific Islander, despite accounting for only 10% of the population, an acute shortage of affordable housing is a major contributing factor. On Maui 52% of homes are sold to non residents, and 60% of condos and apartments have gone to investors and second homeowners with vacation properties remaining empty for much of the year. A controversial influx of wealthy celebrities has resulted in a negative backlash by the disposessed. Policies to deal with homelessness include the removal of  people  from sidewalks, illegalization of sleeping at most parks and beaches  and  “cleanups” that displace the homeless to the outskirts of the city, away from the eyes of tourist.

Today tourism and the U.S. military are the significant drivers of Hawai’i’s $97 billion economy. Hawai’i has one of the most onerous business tax situations and the highest energy costs in the US.  It is the most expensive American State for groceries, according to recent data from Move.org. The average cost of groceries in Honolulu is $200 more than the national average, Hawaiian wages are about 7 percent below comparable mainland averages. Hawai’i now spends $3bn a year importing up to 90% of its food.

Hawai’i has the longest life expectancy out of all 50 states, according to the U.S. Center for Disease Control and Prevention, on average, a person born in Hawai’i can now expect to live until 80.7 years of age. This does not extend to native Hawaiians however for whom life expectancy is 76.2 years. It has long been recognised that the ability of native peoples to adhere to their ancestral knowledge is central to their identity and social relations, and intimately tied to their physical and emotional well-being.

‘Aloha’ the traditional Hawaiian greeting  is not simply a greeting it is a way of being which denotes living in harmony with the people and land around you with mercy,  grace, and kindness. Humility is more highly  esteemed than connections or financial worth.

Since the overthrow of the Hawaiian Kingdom in 1893, Hawaiian entities, like the Nation of Hawai’i, continue to fight to restore Hawai’i to its original status as a sovereign nation. Hawaiians do not all agree on the process of how or if it should be restored.

In 1993, President Bill Clinton signed Public Law 103–150 — an apology to the Hawaiian people for overthrowing their government and stealing their land.