In an intrusively ”woke’ world where ‘trauma’ has become the new buzz word, a sense of perspective has been lost. We would do well to reassess the true meaning of a word which infers very real pain and suffering, now increasingly monopolised and trivialised to convey the potential pain of hurt feelings. In the aftermath of the wars in which millions of veterans were and continue to be traumatised, it is timely to remember the sacrifice of the generations who granted us the space in which we can choose to debate rather than pontificate.
Trauma experience includes but is not limited to domestic and childhood sexual abuse, gender abuse and the PTSD endured by veterans. Comparisons are odious and pointless for the pain of another can never be fully realised yet there can be few worse examples of trauma than that experienced by the veterans of global conflict. It is a beginning to remember that everyone will experience trauma of one kind or another during their lives, exposure to such events is common and with support most will fully recover. Of those who have experienced severe trauma, 1 in 3 go on to develop PTSD from which they can recover with therapy. Women are more likely to experience PTSD than men and veterans are more likely than civillians. Complex PTSD (CPTSD) is a result of compounded trauma over time, related to prolonged or repetitive exposure to a series of traumatic events within which individuals perceive few or no chance of escape. Criteria surely met in combat.
A deepening recognition of the effects of trauma whether physical, emotional or psychological emerged from the human wreckage of two world wars in which all were affected with men bearing the brunt of both physical and psychological injury. In WW1 the term ‘shell shock’ described what was initially assumed to be the response to continual bombardment by munitions. Soldiers became mentally frozen in time, incapable of performing their duties, their shaking bodies demonstrating the fragmentation which occurs when pushed beyond the limits of human endurance. In 1914, soldiers began to report medical symptoms after combat, including tinnitus, amnesia, headaches, dizziness, tremors, mutism and hypersensitivity to noise. The symptoms resembled those that would be expected in brain injury however many showed no signs of head wounds and had not been exposed to artillery fire.
Recuperation programmes gradually replaced accusations of malingering and field hospitals offered brief respite before combatants were returned to military duties with predictable long term consequences. An estimated 40% of casualties sustained at the Battle of the Somme were shell-shocked, an epidemic of psychiatric casualties which could not be sustained militarily or in financial terms. In 1917 the Battle of Paschendale exemplified the horrors of war with 300,000 British and 260,000 German casualties, yet there were relatively low numbers of shell shock. One reason being that by 1917 “shell shock” was entirely banned as a diagnosis in the British Army, replaced by the term ‘battle fatigue’. Mention of it was censored even in medical journals In an effort to avoid medicalisation which would allow for disability pensions while a psychological diagnosis enabled men to be categorized as ‘Uninjured’ and returned to the front. Accusations of cowardice continued with 306 men put on trial and executed. Today many such soldiers would be diagnosed with CPTSD.
Treatments varied widely according to prevailing medical and military views. If symptoms persisted the casualty was evacuated to a dedicated psychiatric centre further behind the lines. In rare cases the soldier was discharged home to a sanitorium.The condition was poorly understood, procedures were brutal and included electric shock treatment. Therapist, Lewis Yealland, practised a form of therapy based on punishment, his book Hysterical Disorders of Warfare describes a patient unsuccessfully subjected to numerous treatments for his mutism over a 9 month period. These included strong application of electricity to his throat, lit cigarette ends applied to the tip of his tongue, and “hot plates” placed in the back of his mouth. By 1918 there were so many officers and men with shell shock that 19 British military hospitals were wholly devoted to the treatment of cases. Ten years after the war, 65,000 veterans of the war were still receiving treatment in Britain with shell shock victims still remaining in hospital in France in 1960. In the advent of WW2, the term ‘shell shock’ had been replaced by ‘combat stress’ redefined in 1980 as PTSD ‘a condition resulting after experiencing or witnessing a terrifying event which later leads to mental health problems.’ With little understanding of the mechanisms involved, unethical psychiatric interventions occurred. Psychiatrists Roy Grinker and Frederick Hanson, implemented mandatory psychoanalysis using sodium pentothal truth serum treatments, intended to identify malingerers among soldiers claiming “exhaustion”. By 1944, treatment plans suggested a programme of sedatives to secure rest, intravenous barbiturates to promote mental catharsis, assisting in the recall of any suppressed episode and use of drugs acting directly on the autonomic nervous system. Treatments now known to be harmful.
For most veterans the wounds remained hidden, they returned to their families forever changed. Current research shows a correllation with helplessness and PTSD. In a time when masculine attributes of strength, endurance and the perceived role of protector defined core identity for males, stoically enduring pain was a factor in hundreds of thousands of combat veterans who suffered in silence. Reluctance to admit or discuss traumatic experience is a key factor in PTSD. On return home 30% of WW2 prisoners of war diagnosed with PTSD experienced marital problems as opposed to 11% of veterans without PTSD.
Beween 1955 and 1975, the United States sent 2.7 million combatants to fight in Vietnam, 700,000 needed some form of psychological treatment as a result. The number of traumatised veterans attempting to reintegrate into their communities on return was overwhelming. Disability claims alleging psychological injury as a result of combat were relentlessly denied; for the duration of the Vietnam War not a single diagnosis relating to stress exposure was ever accepted. In 1980, the DSM-III, the psychiatrist’s bible, was published and included the newly identified condition of PTSD. With women now allowed in combat roles a study mandated by Congress in 1983 found that 30% of men and 27% of women veterans had experienced PTSD at some point.
During their deployment in Iraq and Afghanistan, approximately 380,000 U.S. troops, about 19% of those deployed, were estimated to have sustained brain injuries from explosive weapons and devices. This prompted the U.S. Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) to open up a $10 million study of the blast effects on the human brain. The study revealed that while the brain remains initially intact immediately after low level blast effects, the chronic inflammation afterwards is what ultimately leads to many cases of PTSD. Unprovoked angry outbursts, along with reckless and self-destructive behaviour, are neurological markers for brain injury and among the diagnostic criteria for PTSD. There is a correlation between PTSD and social isolation, increased risk of substance abuse and incarceration. In the 1970s, 25% of all incarcerated people identified as military veterans.
The physiological and psychological effects of trauma are now well recognised, informed care is the accepted standard of medical treatment while a few decades ago its mere existence was doubted by its own professionals. Each generation fashions its own standards of belief, drawing upon the best which has gone before and discarding what is outmoded. We can best judge efficacy by outcome, a strengthening or a weakening of the social structure. By this reckoning we have made an error of judgement in recent decades in redefining male/female attributes.
‘Woke’ ideology, sold to us as ‘awareness of social inequality’ is a wolf in sheep’s clothing, strengthened by an alliance of narcissistic minorities employing victim consciousness to impose their views on the majority. A focus upon ‘toxic masculinity’ as the root cause of disempowerment was initially met publicly by a combination of concerned confusion, assumed guilt and aquiessence. Ironically the very space which allowed discussion was won by the qualities and atttributes now tragically trashed. The public tide is however turning.
As we deepen our awareness of female trauma we must also lament the pain of grandfathers, fathers and sons born too soon to benefit from a more enlightened approach, we can and should at least honour their sacrifice. ‘Toxic masculinity’ is a misnomer beloved by those who seek to denigrate the true masculinity on which society ultimately depends for its defence and protection just as surely as it depends upon the creative, nurturing courage of true femininity for its survival. Those who have achieved an inner balance of the two recognise them as complementary rather than adversarial and have respect for both, seeking integration rather than division.
See also: Healing, Triggers and Trauma Memory