Few people realise that the origins of trans ideology can be traced back to the work of one man – sexologist and psychologist Dr. John Money (1921-2006, who believed that a person’s gender identity was a social construct and the result of their upbringing. As such, he proposed that someone could be “taught” to identify differently than their biological sex.
A pioneer in his field of sexuality and gender in 1955. He was the first person to use the word ‘gender’ as opposed to ‘sex’ to draw a distinction between the biological attributes and the behavioural characteristics that differentiate males from females. He founded the world’s first gender-identity clinic at John Hopkins University in Baltimore in the US in 1966, specialising in the psychological and medical treatment of transgender patients. His work became notorious through the Reimer transgender case.
David Reimer was born Bruce Reimer in Winnipeg, Canada, in 1965. He and his twin brother Brian, were the first children of a rural teenage couple, Janet and Ron Reimer. Their twin boys were born with normal male genitalia but when the twins were seven months old their mother noticed that both of them were having trouble urinating. A doctor diagnosed them both with phimosis, a relatively common condition involving the foreskin that can be easily corrected by circumcision.
What should have been a routine operation became a nightmare. During surgery Janet and Ron were informed that Bruce had suffered severe injuries to his penis, the injury had been caused by an electro-cautery needle, a device sometimes used in circumcision to seal blood vessels as it cuts. Through mechanical malfunction, doctor error or both, the penis was destroyed. The child’s mother described his injury. “It was blackened… It was like a little string. And it went right up to the base, up to his body.” Over the next few days, the burnt tissue dried and broke away in pieces.
Doctors were unable to perform a reconstruction, the consultant surgeon informed them John would be ‘unable to consummate marriage or have normal heterosexual relations; he will have to recognise that he is incomplete, physically defective, and that he must live apart’. Phallic reconstruction, difficult today, was in its infancy in the 1960’s – the plastic surgeon explained the limitations, the phallus would be constructed from flesh farmed from Bruce’s thigh or abdomen: “Such a penis would not, of course, resemble a normal organ in colour, texture or erectile capability, …It would serve as a conduit for urine, but that is all.”
The parents visited countless specialists in the hope of finding some alternative, but there was nothing to be done, until they heard of John Money and the John Hopkins gender-identity clinic in Baltimore. Money had earned himself a reputation in the US as the leading expert on gender disorders, here at at was someone who might be able to help their son. Janet and Ron trusted him but were cautious, Money however was insistent, urging surgery to remove Bruce’s testicles and construct a vagina as soon as possible. He also proposed that when the child turned 11 or 12 he could be given female hormones to complete the transition. In desperation and against the advice of other doctors, they agreed to allow their then 22-month-old son to undergo clinical castration and the construction of female genitalia.
The parents followed the expert’s instructions and raised their child under the pretence that he had been born a girl. Bruce became Brenda and was put in dresses and given dolls houses and a sewing machine to play with. No one outside of the immediate family knew about the complicated medical situation, even twin brother Kevin was led to believe that ‘Brenda’ had always been a little girl. Despite his parents’ best efforts the child always felt that something was wrong. Speaking in interviews later in life, he explained how both he and his brother sensed there was something out of the ordinary about him. He rejected his mother’s offers to put on makeup with her and he tore off the lacy clothes she dressed him in. Problems at home extended to school. ‘Brenda’ was referred to by classmates as ‘cave woman’, teased by classmates for his “masculine gait” and for standing to pee in the girl’s bathroom. Around age 11, he confided to a psychologist that he had an intense fear that ‘something [had] been done to [his] genital organs’.
During an interview Kevin later commented “I recognized Brenda as my sister but she never, ever acted the part. She’d get a skipping rope for a gift, and the only thing we’d use that for was to tie people up or whip people with it. It was never used for what it was bought for. She played with my toys: Tonkatoys, dump trucks. Toys like this sewing machine she got just sat.” “When I say there was nothing feminine, I mean there was nothing feminine. She walked like a guy. She talked about guy things, didn’t give a crap about cleaning house, getting married, wearing makeup….We both wanted to play with guys, build forts and have snowball fights and play army.” Enrolled in Girl Scouts ‘Brenda’ was miserable. ‘Brenda’ agreed. “I remember making daisy chains and thinking, ‘If this is the most exciting thing in Girl Scouts, forget it… I kept thinking of the fun stuff my brother was doing in Cubs.”
Unknown to their parents, the siblings had been subjected to sexual abuse over years during annual visits to see Dr. Money in Baltimore. From around the age of six, they were questioned by him regarding their sexual desires and preferences, shown naked pictures of other children and of adults having sex. He asked them to strip off their clothes and inspect each other’s genitals, sometimes while five or six other colleagues observed. Money would take photographs and would often ask the young twins to ‘play at thrusting movements and copulation’, pretending to have sex in various positions while he watched them. When the twins refused to do as he said, he would reportedly become irate and scream at them until they complied.
The children grew to dread these annual visits especially when approaching the age of eight the subject of further surgery was broached in order to complete the construction of a vagina for ‘Brenda’. It was Money’s belief that a psychological sex change could not be completed without physically changing the appearance of the genitals. This was what ‘Brenda’ had begun to dread, an aversion to surgery came partially from an intense fear of hospitals and needles but also from the sense of being trapped into an alien gender.
In 1972, when ‘Brenda’ was seven, Money published his first findings portrayed as a resounding success. “The girl already preferred dresses to pants enjoyed wearing her hair ribbons, bracelets, and frilly blouses, and loved being her daddy’s little sweetheart. Throughout childhood, her stubbornness and the abundant physical energy she shares with her twin brother and expends freely have made her a tomboyish girl, but nonetheless a girl.” This was untrue but accepted by a media championing his innovative work which in time helped to legitimise the practice of sex-reassignment surgery for thousands of children across the world.
As ‘Brenda’ began to approach puberty, the intense alienation from his own body became unbearable. Money reported that “the mere mention of undergoing hormone treatments or surgery induced ‘panic so intense that it’s impossible to broach any conversation on such matters without the child fleeing the room, screaming”. Doctors, psychologists and parents persuaded the child to commence oestrogen by age 12. On a final visit in 1976, in an attempt at reassurance, Money introduced a transsexual adult who had undergone similar procedures. This culminated in ‘Brenda’ running to the top of the clinic building and threatening to to throw himself off. When Money visited the parents once more at their home in 1979 the twins attempted to hide in the basement for the duration of his stay.
One by one, the medical team that had tried to implement treatment withdrew. In March 1980, the boy’s father picked him up from his weekly psychiatrist appointment, drove him to get ice cream, and told him the full story. Bruce was now free to live how he wished and began transitioning to his biological birth gender. At age 14, he stopped living as a girl entirely, by his 16th birthday he had changed his name to David had undergone a double mastectomy, and was taking male hormones. He also underwent surgery to construct crude, non-functioning male genitalia.
In 1990 David got married and adopted his wife’s three children, for a while life became more settled. It was during this period that the true nature of Money’s experimentation on him became public. Milton Diamond, a fellow sexologist and academic rival of Money, had long believed that the experiment was fundamentally flawed. In 1993 along with Keith Sigmundson who had previously overseen the psychiatric treatment, he decided to set the record straight about the research. Diamond and Sigmundson’s controversial paper was published in 1997, convincing many paediatricians that Money had mislead the scientific community.
After decades of silence David decided it was important that the truth of the story should be told as a warning to others and appeared on Oprah, bringing an overwhelmingly compassionate response towards the brothers and anger towards the medical fraternity. This could have been the beginning of the end for the flawed gender hypothesis but the medical community hesitated and the opportunity was lost.
Transgender issues inevitably have far reaching consequences. The secret had destroyed the Reimer family, the father sank into alcoholism and the mother attempted suicide. Kevin suffered depression and was diagnosed schizophrenic, he died from an anti depressant overdose in July 2002. On May 2nd, 2002, David Reimer’s wife told him she wanted a divorce, two days later he committed suicide by fire arm. He was 38 years old.
John Moneys flawed gender hypothesis, resurrected in an age of self indulgence, continues to blight the lives of innumerable vulnerable children and adolescents. We have embraced a legacy of indoctrination which has left an entire generation unable to discern a most basic fact – that biology is the foundation of life. It is the structural makeup of an individual’s 23rd pair of chromosomes which determine masculine or feminine gender. This is further coloured and influenced by environment, thoughts and feelings which enrich or deplete individual expression, dependent upon perception and belief. The mercifully rare but real genetic condition of absent or ambiguous genitalia is biological in origin. An infant’s external genitals may appear to be neither male or female, or the baby may have characteristics of both sexes, a mismatch of internal and external sex organs.
To understand the current epidemic of body dysmorphia which covers a spectrum of psychological disorders we must also look to the underlying cause of the mental health issues currently affecting millions globally.
See Also :