TRANSITION OF WEALTH AND POWER

AN £18 BILLION RECALIBRATION OF ROYAL FINANCES

After the pageantry and spectacle which captured the imagination of millions, is it time to pause and reflect? The seamless and instant transition of power following the death of Queen Elizabeth was impressive.  Apart from the 1,000 years of practice which makes perfect, there is an obvious incentive in ensuring that land, property and possessions of a hereditary monarchy pass unimpeded from one monarch to the next. King Charles lll  inherited not only the throne after the death of his mother but also her private fortune and the Duchy of Lancaster. In turn  the Duchy of Cornwall  has  passed to Prince William as heir.

A further vital component to ‘keeping it in the family’, is to ensure the process is unencumbered by the restrictive tax laws which govern citizens. British monarchs are not required to reveal their private finances, however Forbes estimates the Queens personal wealth  from her ownership of art, jewellery investments and real estates including Balmoral Castle in Scotland and Sandringham House at £500 million.  This will pass to Charles intact for unlike his subjects, the monarchs estate is not liable for inheritance tax, this is ‘to safeguard the erosion of of the sovereigns wealth”.  In addition, the monarch receives income from the Sovereign Grant (the royal purse) to fund official duties.  In 2020-21 the queen was paid  £85.9m with  £82.4m paid in  2019/20.  

THE PERSONAL WEALTH OF THE NEW KING WILL THEREFORE INCREASE TO £600 MILLION UNENCUMBERED BY THE 40% INHERITANCE TAX WHICH WOULD HAVE ENRICHED THE COUNTRY BUT DIMINISHED HIS INHERITANCE BY £200 MILLION.

The Crown Estate administers property valued at £14.1 billion and operates as a hereditary Trust, protecting its real estate commercial business portfolio.  The reigning monarch owns the Crown Estate, including the Crown Jewels  ‘in right of the Crown’ i.e. for the duration of their reign. It is managed independently by the Commissioners  and the surplus income after expenditure goes to the government. The Crown Estates can not be sold either by the monarch or by the government but are held in trust.The real estate is protected and handed down from monarch to monarch, Its classification as “the sovereign’s public estate” ensures the seamless transition of ownership within the royal family.

  • Holdings include , Buckingham Palace, Kensington Palace and land and almost £8bn in London properties, particularly the West End.
  • The estate also controls 7,920 km of agricultural land and forest as well as about half the land along the shoreline of England, Wales and Northern Ireland.
  • Naturally occurring gold and silver in the UK, collectively known as “Mines Royal”, are managed by the Crown Estate and leased to mining operators.

THE VAST ESTATES OF THE DUCHY OF LANCASTER AND THE DUCHY OF CORNWALL OWNED BY THE ROYAL FAMILY, DATE BACK TO MEDIEVAL TIMES, THEY ORIGINATE IN  HOLDINGS SEIZED BY A SUCCESSION OF KINGS AND ACCRUED OVER TIME THROUGH MARRAIGE, GIFTS AND INHERITANCE.

The Duchy  of Lancaster was created by King Henry lV in the Middle Ages to provide a source of independent income to the sovereign. It is a private estate now owned by King Charles lll, currently valued at £652.8 million. The net income of the Duchy is paid to the reigning monarch. A private estate of commercial, agricultural and residential assets, the Duchy consists of 45,550 acres of land holdings, including rural estates and farmland, urban developments, historic buildings  including 10 castles and commercial properties across England and Wales, particularly in Cheshire, Staffordshire, Derbyshire, Lincolnshire, Yorkshire, Lancashire and the Savoy Estate in London. The  Duchy  benefits from two key tax breaks at variance to the way it does business, although it operates like a land company it pays neither corporation tax nor capital gains tax.  In 1993, Parliament had voiced the public disquiet following an expectation that public money would be used to renovate and refurbish Windsor Castle which had been extensively damaged by fire. Subsequently the queen volunteered to pay income tax and capital gains tax but as a newly-found Treasury memo states:  “one of the things the palace has insisted on is that there should be no surrender of the Duchy revenues.”  As of March 2022, the Duchy is reported to have generated an estimated (mostly tax free) surplus income of some £227.88 million between 2010 and 2020 with a net surplus  of £24 million in the current fiscal year.

The Duchy of Cornwall  is a private estate established by charter In 1337 by King Edward Vlll  from lands forfeited from Earls and gifted to his son to provide a source of independent income for future heirs. His son, Prince Edward, aged 7 years old, was later said to have comforted his tenants in many ways ‘most notably pardoning certain money payments in 1357 on account of The Black Death’!  In 1536 the Duchy acquired further land and wealth confiscated from the church by King Henry Vlll in the Dissolution of the monasteries. Today the Duchy which has now passed to the Duke of Cambridge is valued at £1.3 billion and according to the ‘Prince of Wales’ website made profits of  $24 million in 2022.  The Duchy owns more than 130,000 acres across 20 counties in England and Wales, stretching from Devon to Kent, and Carmarthenshire to Nottinghamshire. Much of the estate comprises farmland, along with homes and commercial properties, forests, rivers, coastline, about a third of the Dartmoor national park, once used for mining minerals such as tin and copper and Dartmoor Prison. According to the 2022 Integrated Annual Report, the duchy includes 2,640 leases and tenancy agreements, 260 farms, some $67 million in development land and around $397 million in commercial property.

The Duchy has been accused of resembling a medieval fiefdom, retaining rights and privileges which whether enacted or not are out of step with modern democracy.

  • The Duchy of Cornwall has the right to claim “Bona Vacantia” within Cornwall. That is to say, where property within Cornwall becomes ownerless, it belongs to the Duke of Cornwall instead of the government.
  • The Duke also administers the estates of people who die without a will, even if the rightful owner is eventually traced.
  • The Duchy of Cornwall automatically owns all mines in Cornwall, irrespective of the individual ownership of the land. This includes mines under the sea extending beyond Cornwall but originating there.
  • The Duke owns “treasure troves” in Cornwall and elsewhere in England and Wales, if an archaeologist finds, for example, a buried Anglo-Saxon coin hoard, the Treasure Act would give a relevant museum an absolute right to purchase the find, if not taken up, it belongs to the finder. For any other kind of archaeological find, the landowner, not the finder, has the interest.  The Duchy is exempt outright and has absolute title to any such finds.
  • Prince Charles took court action against the owner of Wheal Roots Tin Mine – known more recently as the Poldark Mine – where the hit BBC series Poldark was filmed. The mine has been forced to close after the 71 year old owner refused to pay rent to Prince Charles on the lease of the underground passages that make up much of the tourist attraction. The Duchy of Cornwall is the legally registered owner of the mineral rights at the mine, as it is at other sites around the county.

IF IT LOOKS LIKE A DUCK AND QUACKS LIKE A DUCK AND SWIMS LIKE A DUCK, IT’S PROBABLY A DUCK…

The adage comes to mind when considering the questionable tax status of holdings registered as private estates and therefore not considered to be a company, making them exempt from taxes.  In 2009 MPs called for an investigation into Prince Charles tax affairs when he was accused of avoiding capital gains tax. It was argued by the Duchy of Cornwall  that  it has no access to capital gains ‘as these are  reinvested for the benefit of future dukes’ and that if corporation tax was paid in addition to  income tax the Duchy would effectively be taxed twice on the same income. (As routinely happens to pensioners who paid tax on income during their working lives but are again taxed on their pensions.)  King Charles later voluntarily paid Income tax on profits, and William  now has the choice of whether to continue this practice.

WHY THE RICH GET RICH AND THE POOR GET POORER

  • In 1992 the queen agreed to pay voluntary income tax in a deal which avoided her paying some £28m in inheritance tax on property in her mother’s Will, which included works of art, antiques and race horses, estimated at between £50 and £70 million. 
  • The Queen Mother gifted jewellery ‘on paper’ to her grandchildren which was said to be still in her possession following her death, representing a loss of millions in taxation due to the government.
  • The taxpayer covers council tax for Royal properties that are vacant or used as staff accommodation. In 2009 it was estimated the queen paid just £1,375 in rates for Buckingham Palace which has 775 rooms, because of Westminster’s low tax bands.

BRITAIN’S GENEROUS TRUST LAWS ENSURE THAT THE COUNTRY’S LARGEST FORTUNES REMAIN INTACT. “MONEY CAN STAY IN THE TRUST AND CASCADE DOWN FROM GENERATION TO GENERATION WITH  NO INHERITANCE TAX PAID ON IT”.

The Aristocracy ensures medieval wealth is protected: The Duke of Westminster  is currently the largest landowner in Britain, the only family that owns more land than the King himself. His ancestor, Hugh Lupus, the head hunter of William the Conquerer received what is now the county of Cheshire in 1066 for protecting the region from the ethnic Welsh. 600 years later another ancestor married the 12-year-old Mary Davis, whose dowry included 500 acres of swampy bog west of the City of London. The swamp was drained and eventually became Mayfair and Belgravia, the most exclusive parts of London today.  In 2016 the current Duke inherited his £9.8 billion fortune on the death of his father at the age of 26. While this inheritance would usually attract a tax liability of 40%  (£4 billion) astute trust planning meant that no tax was payable. Details of the Grosvenor family’s tax planning – which is legal under UK law, reignited the debate over the loopholes which allow the rich to largely escape inheritance dues by holding most of their assets in trusts. John Christensen, director of the Tax Justice Network, said: ‘It is time for us to address the whole issue of whether trusts should be used to hold assets in perpetuity and whether it is appropriate for them to be used at all in this way… Clearly this is not a case of someone being vulnerable and needing assets protected. It is quite simply a means of circumventing inheritance tax laws and it is time for it to be challenged.’

Many UK citizens would welcome the opportunity to be in a position to pay rather than avoid  tax as millions worry about the spiralling cost of living and how to face the coming winter bills.  In 2022 more than 14.5 million people, one in five of the UK population (22%) are in poverty.  Of these, 8.1 million are working-age adults, 4.3 million are children and 2.1 million are pensioners.

In 2021, the average full time UK salary was £38,131  and £13,549 for a part-time role.The poverty line for a single person was £147 a week and  for a couple with two young children it was £354. According to the European Banking Authority there are 3,519 bankers working in the UK making more than €1m a year (£880,000).

As the pound rocks, the government currently stands accused of introducing a “simply staggering, huge tax cut for richer households and the super-wealthy ” while allowing hundreds of thousands of already-struggling families to fall deeper into poverty.”

WAKE UP PEOPLE