MISSING THE POINT – Transgender and Perception

Controversy continues regarding the production at the Globe Theatre London which portrays Joan of Arc as non-binary, using pronouns ‘they’ and ‘them’. Vocal critics including J K Rowling, accuse the theatre of violating history. The play ‘I Joan’ (perhaps more accurately titled ‘I John”), sparked furious response with many objecting to identity politics portraying a pious 15th century Catholic peasant girl as a closet transgender hero.

A patron saint of France, Joan is celebrated for her role in restoring France to the French in a major military victory over the English. The concept of binary gender would have been meaningless to Joan, her achievements were all the more impressive because she was a woman. One in a long line of inspirational female warriors, Joan’s achievements are diminished by suggesting she was gender neutral, a denial that a woman can be a warrior. In the long fought battle for equality, respect and celebration of femininity, this does little to empower young women today. Rather than continue the they/them debate, so offensive to many, we might instead honour her strength and exemplary courage as a woman.

The true courage of Joan of Arc was not simply that she led the French army to victory but that she dared to listen to the voices, which today would be termed channelled communication, informing her of a mission to restore France.  She resisted the guidance from the age of 13 , before finally seeking an audience with the King of France at age 17. Inspired by her integrity, Charles Vll accepted her story and her campaigns began. Joan was a religious icon long before she was adopted by the feminist movement, a true appreciation of her life can only be gained through an understanding of the time in which she lived. In a medieval world dominated by Catholicism, Joan never expressed herself as anything other than one entrusted with a message from God. Her faith meant that she would have rejected the identity politics of both feminism and transgender or queer ideology of today. To suggest otherwise is profoundly disrespectful of her deeply religous beliefs. During Joan’s campaigns she spent long hours immersed in prayer and rigorous fasting and sought the company of members of Franciscans, Dominicans, Augustinians and Carmelite orders.

REFUTING CROSS DRESSING AS LESBIAN AND TRANSGENDER CLAIMS

Joan was imprisoned, tortured and sentenced to death, not because of any gender beliefs but because she refused to deny that her voices came from God via the saints. Such direct communication was viewed as witchcraft by the church because it threatened the position of the clergy as the only spiritual intermediary. Joan initially wore men’s clothing in order to avoid detection and to enable her to mix with uncouth soldiers. We know that when camped with her army she always slept either with her pants and tunic securely fastened, or in full plate armour to provide a still greater degree of protection. During her long imprisonment, Joan refused to wear womens garments in an attempt  to protect against sexual assault. Her accusers used this as the excuse to accuse her of violating divine law for dressing as a man. A number of the tribunal members themselves later admitted that Joan had said she clung to her soldier’s outfit as a desperate means of discouraging rape. The  clothing had numerous cords by which the long boots and hosen could both be fastened to the tunic, thereby making it difficult for a rapist to pull them off.  She also stated that her saints had ordered her to wear it principally for such protective purposes. Virginity was associated with holy women and rape would be used to weaken her position at her trial. 

In the full transcript of her trial, Guillaume Manchon, chief notary and parish priest of Saint Nicholas Church in Rouen stated:  ‘…at that time she was dressed in male clothing, and kept complaining that she could not do without it, fearing that the guards would violate her in the night…  ‘once when she cried out [for help], the Earl himself came to her aid in response to her cries, and if he hadn’t arrived, the guards would have raped her…’ Joan said that if it would please the lord judges to put her in a safe place in which she would not be afraid, then she was prepared to put the female clothing back on... Friar Martin Ladvenu (an assessor at her trial) wrote:  “On the day of the Holy Trinity, when Joan was accused of relapse, she replied that while she was lying in bed her guards removed her female clothing from the bed in which she was lying, and gave her instead the male clothing; and, although she asked these guards to return the female clothing, so she could leave her bed to go to the latrine; they refused to give it to her, telling her that she would not have anything else but the male clothing.”

In 1431, Joan of Arc was sentenced to death in a mock trial for the crime of heresy, refusing to deny the messages she said were from God. Burned at the stake in Rouen she is one in a long line of women persecuted, tortured and put to death for their faith. Twenty five years after her death she was exonerated and five hundred years later she was canonised by the church which had condemned her. Not a hero but a heroine who continues to inspire.

There are increasing signs that the public is tiring of the demand that we all capitulate to extreme transgender ideology which chooses to interpret the world through a myopic lens. While fully acknowledging that certain individuals experience body dysmorphia, transgender issues and gender conflict, it is important to note that this  is and always has been a minority.  Unquestionably, all people should be accorded the same rights and respect but this does not invest any with a right to impose their self created acronyms on others. The 100 plus current gender pronouns we are currently asked to use include: He/She — Zie, Sie, Ey, Ve, Tey, E. Him/Her — Zim, Sie, Em, Ver, Ter, Em. His/Her — Zir, Hir, Eir, Vis, Tem, Eir. His/Hers — Zis, Hirs, Eirs, Vers, Ters, Eirs.

The ever growing list of gender options includes bi-gender, multi-gender, gender neutral, agender, androgynous, gender fluid, genderqueer, ceterosexual, demisexual, trixic, skoliosexual, pansexual…..Paraphilia, (sexual attraction to trees) fraysexual (people who feel sexual attraction only to people they don’t know or don’t know well) aceflux ( someone whose capacity for sexual attraction changes over time), trigender (a blending of three genders).

Collapse of societies has been linked to self perception and the loss of and search for cultural, personal and gender identity. We would seem to be well on our way.