SEXUAL ABUSE COVER UP – Anglican Clergy

THE QUEEN IS THE SUPREME GOVERNOR OF THE CHURCH OF ENGLAND, THE LARGEST CHRISTIAN DENOMINATION IN THE COUNTRY WITH OVER A MILLION REGULAR WORSHIPERS.

November 2020: The newly published Report on the Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse within the Church of England, gives a damning account of failure to respond to child victims and survivors of sexual abuse by people associated with the church. The report states that alleged perpetrators received more support than their victims, adding to the trauma already suffered. Attempts to report abuse were covered up by a church hierarchy who were often the very perpetrators. Safeguarding concerns were under reported with cases hidden, giving an inaccurate impression of the scale of the problem. In 2018, there were 2,504 safeguarding concerns reported to dioceses about either children or vulnerable adults yet there have been only 390 perpetrators convicted since the 1940s.

Offending clergy were supported and shielded by the most powerful people in the land including Prince Charles and Lord George Carey, the former Archbishop of Canterbury who refused to  believe the allegations against Bishop Peter Ball, supporting him in the face of numerous allegations. In 2018 Carey was subsequently forced to resign after the UK Child Sex Abuse Report found that he had covered up allegations of sexual abuse within the church. 

  • Clerics benefited from deferential treatment, defended by their peers in an environment where power was invested without accountability to external or independent agencies or individuals.
  • The moral authority of clergy was widely perceived as beyond reproach by a naive public who failed to question their conduct. A tribal culture flourished where loyalty to peers exceeded consideration of the welfare or protection of children.
  • Members of a church hierarchy ignored reports of abuse, reintegrating abusers into church life, perpetuating further abuse.
  • Bishops ignored  safeguarding guidelines issued byThe House of Bishops, there is no requirement in canon law to require clergy to follow safeguarding guidelines  despite Ministerial guidelines to do so.
  • The Enquiry found that offending was repeatedly minimised and justified.

Reverend Ian Hughes was convicted in 2014 of downloading 8,000 indecent images of children, more than 800 were graded Category A level, the most serious, involving “penetrative sexual activity; images involving sexual activity with an animal or sadism”. . It emerged during the hearing that The Bishop of Chester, Rt Reverend Peter Foster, declined to accept the seriousness of the offending of Hughes. He maintained his view, expressed in a letter to the President of Tribunals, that “many people who download child pornography believe it to be different from direct abuse of a child.” Forster had blocked a life-time ban from ministry being imposed on any minister jailed for pornography, recommending instead that Rev.Ian Hughes receive a 20 year ban.

  • Bishop Victor Whitsey was ordained in 1949 and was Bishop of Hertford, in the Diocese of St Albans, in 1971 and then Bishop of Chester, in 1974, a position which he held until his retirement in early 1982, despite 13 complaints made to Cheshire Constabulary about his serial abuse. In January 2018 an adult male disclosed to a vicar that he had been indecently assaulted by Whitsey as a child in the early 1980s. The safeguarding advisor was informed and also the Bishop of Chester Peter Forster who failed to undertake any enquiries. The complainant told the Enquiry that he had again informed Bishop Forster in 2002 when he was offered counselling but no further action was taken.
  • Further accusations were made against Whitsey by two males, stating he had sexually abused them as children between 1974 and 1981, during his time as the Bishop of Chester. A further 10 potential victims, including teenagers and young adults of both sexes were later identified.
  • In 1979, a 13 year old girl and her brother, both members of the church were invited to meet Whitsey during a time when her father (a vicar), had left the family home. The girl was left alone in a room with him for around half an hour, she described how he gave her a ‘body hug’ and told her that ‘men have urges’ telling her to sit on his knee, she was aware of his erection and recalled him quoting from the Bible ‘Suffer little children to come unto me” before stroking her through her clothes and ‘rubbing against me’. She was then ordered to leave the room and her brother was sent in. She did not disclose the abuse at the time as she ‘wouldn’t have known who to tell’ as the family were already being ostracized by the church because the family was splitting up. In April 2015, while attending the internment of her mother’s ashes with her brother at the church in Cheshire, they noticed Whitsey’s signature in the Book of Remembrance, her brother stated ‘That bastard abused me and she answered ‘Me too”.
  • Police enquiries showed that of 19 complainants, it was “clear that those who reported abuse had previously disclosed details of their allegations to the Church”.

Robert Waddington (the Dean of Manchester Cathedral from 1984 to1993) was the subject of allegations of child sexual abuse, from the 1950s to 2004.  Throughout his long career as a paedophile, he maintained an image as a respected churchman, cultivating an illusion of goodness while abusing  boys in England and Australia where he also served. Eli Ward, who has waived his right to anonymity, said his abuser was a “very clever guy”…”It would progress to picking me up, go to his house, stay over and then stay in his room and so on over a period of time, little by little, very strategic planning… it’s very much insidious planning and grooming, very clever.”  Waddington was popular with the choristers at Manchester Cathedral because of his use of language that was “shocking, unexpected and lavatorial.” Lord Hope, former arch bishop of York, resigned from his position after a report found ‘systemic failures’ to begin a prosecution before Waddington’s death in 2007, he had been allowed to continue to officiate on the grounds of his age and frailty, seemingly without any consideration of the risks to children with whom he came into contact.

The Enquiry gave details of an unnamed priest,  a prominent member of the Church of England who was repeatedly reported to the church hierarchy, accused of sexual abuse between the 1970s and 2003. No action was taken.

  • At the age of 16 the claimant was befriended by the priest in question and invited to visit him at his home where he was given alcohol and questioned about his sexuality. He  was asked whether he became sexually aroused by fighting, the priest then began to act in a verbally aggressive manner ordering him to remove his clothes and beginning ‘to fight’ with him. When both were naked the youth was  pinned down on the bed and the priest attempted to rape him.
  • At the age of  18  the survivor disclosed the abuse to a priest during confession. He was asked for details of the assault, and after the confession the priest started to kiss him passionately. They subsequently engaged in a romantic and physical relationship for around a year, before  the priest in question became a bishop.
  • From the 1980s onwards, the survivor disclosed his abuse by the bishop to a number of senior Church of England priests and bishops but said that none of them offered any advice as to what he should do. Some viewing his disclosure as part of the sacrament of confession and so viewed it as confidential. One bishop, to whom he disclosed in 1987, promised to make discreet inquiries but nothing happened.
  • In 2003, he disclosed his abuse to Bishop Tim Thornton (now Bishop of Lambeth), resident at Lambeth Palace as a senior adviser to the Archbishop of Canterbury.  (Chair of the Board of Trustees of The Children’s Society since 2010 and a former Member of the House of Lords.) Thornton, formerly Bishop to the Forces, Bishop for the Falkland Islands, area Bishop of Sherborne from 2001 to 2008 and diocesan Bishop of Truro, told him to report it to the Church. No record exists of that meeting and Bishop Thornton states that he does not remember it. The  Elliott Safeguarding Review found this lack of memory difficult to countenance: “What is surprising about this is that he (the survivor) would be speaking about a serious and sadistic sexual assault allegedly perpetrated by a senior member of the hierarchy. The fact that these conversations could be forgotten about is hard to accept,” … The survivor had tried repeatedly to alert the Archbishop’s office to critical concerns arising from these denials writing 17 letters to Lambeth Palace expressing concerns about the response of senior clergy. He was ignored on the instruction of the church’s insurers.” The only response he received was a letter from the correspondence secretary, which stated that the Archbishop would “be sure to hold him in his prayers when he hears that you have written again”  

Reverend Trevor Devamanikkam was ordained in 1977.  In March 1984, he moved to a parish in the Bradford diocese, where he remained until 1985. Devamanikkam retired in 1996 but  had permission to officiate in the Diocese of Lincoln until 2009. A complainant Matthew Ineson (an ordained minister) went to the police first in 2013 and then again in 2015. In 2017, the police investigated and charged Devamanikkam who took his own life in June 2017, the day before his court appearance for three counts of buggery and three counts of indecent assault between March 1984 and April 1985, all relating to Reverend Ineson.

Matthew Ineson and his family were religious, Matthew was a member of the church choir and an altar server. In 1984 during a period of family difficulty Matthew went to live with his grandmother, a local priest organised a respite placement and Matthew went to live with Reverend Devamanikkam and his housekeeper. On his second night there, Devamanikkam came into Matthew’s bedroom, put his hand underneath the covers and played with his penis. When asked if he liked it, Matthew Ineson said, no. This continued for two or three nights, and then progressed to Devamanikkam telling Matthew Ineson to share his bed with him indicating that if he did not do so he would be thrown out of the vicarage and would have nowhere to go. While sharing a bed over a number of weeks, Devamanikkam raped Matthew Ineson at least 12 times and also sexually assaulted him. Some  two months later Matthew Ineson’s grandmother came to the vicarage and spoke to Devamanikkam.  Matthew Ineson said that the Bishop of Bradford visited the vicarage next morning and told him that he had to leave, saying that “It’s not my problem where you go but you have to leave here”. No reason was given. Bishop Roy Williamson (then Bishop of Bradford) states that he did not remember visiting the vicarage.  There was no written record of this visit.

Since many high profile cases have involved bishops and their seniors  the Enquiry  concludes  that radical reforms are necessary with responsibility for safeguarding removed from bishops and made mandatory.

See #Letterstopriests