Cui bono? Who benefits?

The definition of madness is said to be repeating the same error while expecting a different outcome. As we watch the oldest democracy in the world slide into deepening chaos and confusion amid the  political wrangling on all sides it seems incomprehensible that a way can not be found to resolve the critical issues.   World markets waver, as potential global vulnerabilities are exposed while those in a position to do so are quietly but hastily shifting euros and dollars around the world. With bank doors firmly  closed Greek citizens que to withdraw their 60 euro daily limit at cash points,  concerned with how to feed their family today and pay their rent and mortgage tomorow.

While acknowledging the many causes of the current chaos including  flagrant tax abuses, corruption and mismanagement by successive governments over many years, it is good to pause and reflect upon who benefited from the profligacy. Was it families, small businesses, the elderly, the poor?  Or as seems more likely was it those in a more fortunate position, able to manipulate the situation to their own advantage.

Cui bono, the Latin adage meaning ‘who benefited’ or ‘to whose benefit‘ used by the Roman Consul Lucius Cassius Longinus Ravilla (127BC) remains a principle of law today. It  is  used to suggest hidden motive or to indicate where the party responsible for something may not be who it first appears to be and to suggest that those responsible for the crime are likely to have something to gain, chiefly of a financial nature.

Is there a crime, if so what is it and who committed it? The personal greed which has immediate gratification as its goal is short sighted and foolish bringing an inevitable fall. The greed which feeds off the impoverished, who having  realised their error  seek resolution  is nothing less than evil. In the not too distant past the penalty for failure to pay ones creditors resulted in being sentenced to the Debtors’ Prison, release came only when the debt had been paid in full. Once incarcerated the unfortunate wretch had even less opportunity to repay the debt and so would languish there, often for years , frequently dying of malnutrition, disease or hopelessness. For those who retained assets, however small, one recourse was to the moneylender who would agree to pay the outstanding amount for agreed interest – a bailout. Faced with no alternative and desperate for a solution the debtor like most of us, would agree to even the most outrageous interest repayment as the only means to secure  his freedom. Frequently this resulted in further impoverishment and a slide into deepening poverty. Unable to repay the moneylender and with no further assets the cycle was repeated and a spiral of debt ensued. We might ask  Cui bono? The answer of course being the moneylender…at least for a time, since in the end the debtor is unable to meet extortionate demands and both lose.

What do we do in these more enlightened times with no Debtors’ Prison to solve the problem?  There are only three solutions, extend the repayment period, wipe the debt, or renegotiate the lone agreement ie lend more money and impose even greater austerity. The latter is in effect the equivalent of the Debtors’ Prison for there is only one result.

Greek bailout with imposed Austerity: Cui bono? 91% of the bailout money didn’t go to Greece but to cover the losses of big banks and speculators who made reckless loans.The Greeks have complied with austerity, cut salaries and spending, privatised, deregulated and raised taxes. Despite this the debt problem has deepened. Austerity is not working. 40% of children now live in poverty, infant mortality has risen by 43% and youth unemployment is almost 50%.

‘Moneylender’ European Union: The economy of the European Union generated a GDP of about €14.303 trillion  in 2014 according to the International Monetary Fund which makes it the largest  economy in the world. Cui bono?

Whatever the outcome of the Greek referendum, years of pain lie ahead for its people. If we are to avoid the same fate we might observe closely the way in in which Greece is ‘helped’  towards its recovery by those who control global economies.  Is the motive to support autonomy by strengthening financial security or a strategy to create dependency through debt. The philosophy of  ‘create a problem, wait for the reaction, offer the solution’ is an effective strategy of control.

Is there another way?  In 2015 Iceland has withdrawn its application for membership of the EU made in 2009 after the global economic crisis. The Icelandic Foreign Minister stated  that Iceland does want to maintain close ties and cooperation with the EU but “Iceland’s interests are better served outside the European Union,”   With a tiny population of 320,000 the country’s former shattered economy is growing faster than that of many EU countries, expanding by 3% in 2013. The island’s approach to its rescue led to a “surprisingly” strong recovery’ the International Monetary Fund’s mission chief to the country said. Foreign visitors have flocked to the island. Tourist revenues for the year to the end of September were 267 billion Icelandic crowns up from 73 billion in the whole of 2008.